1980's
| 1984 | Calvin def. Alma 15-9, 15-10, 15-9 |
| Calvin def. Ohio Northern 7-15, 15-11, 15-17, 15-12 | |
| Calvin def. North Carolina-Greensboro 15-5, 17-15, 14-16, 15-8 | |
| MIT def. Calvin 15-13, 15-10, 13-15, 15-10 | |
| LaVerne, Calif. def. Calvin 15-8, 15-5, 15-6 (4th place nationally) | |
| 1985 | Calvin def. Wis.-Whitewater 15-13, 14-16, 14-16, 15-12, 15-6 |
| Elmhurst, Ill., def. Calvin 15-11, 15-6, 16-14 | |
| 1986 | Calvin def. Buffalo, N.Y. 15-4, 15-11, 15-13 |
| Calvin def. Ohio Northern 5-15, 15-8, 15-6, 15-9 | |
| Calvin def. Wisc.-LaCrosse 15-10, 15-9, 7-15, 15-11 | |
| California-San Diego def. Calvin 15-4, 10-15, 3-15, 15-3, 15-5 (2nd place nationally) | |
| 1987 | Hope def. Buffalo, N.Y., 15-5, 12-15, 15-3, 15-11 |
| Illinois Benedictine def. Hope 8-15, 15-8, 15-11, 12-15, 15-12 | |
| 1988 | Ohio Northern def. Calvin 15-8, 15-13, 11-15, 12-15, 15-5 |
| 1989 | Calvin def. MIT 15-6, 15-8, 15-7 |
| Ohio Northern def. Calvin 15-4, 8-15, 15-7, 15-12 |
1990's
| 1990 | Calvin def. Allegheny, Pa. 13-15, 15-7, 15-6, 16-14 |
| Washington, Mo. def. Calvin 15-11, 15-13, 15-7 | |
| Kalamazoo def. Ohio Northern 16-14, 15-8, 15-12 | |
| Washington, Mo. def. Kalamazoo 15-1, 15-8, 15-5 | |
| 1991 | Wis.-Oshkosh def. Calvin 15-9, 15-9, 15-13 |
| Wis.-Oshkosh def. Kalamazoo 8-15, 16-14, 15-11, 9-15, 16-14 | |
| 1992 | Calvin def. Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 15-10, 15-2, 15-2 |
| Calvin def. Thomas More, Ky. 16-14, 15-12, 8-15, 15-12 | |
| Washington, Mo. def. Calvin, 15-9, 15-7, 13-15, 15-5 | |
| SUNY-Stonybrook def. Calvin 11-15, 15-11, 9-15, 15-6, 15-8 (4th place nationally) | |
| 1993 | Illinois Benedictine def. Kalamazoo 8-15, 15-3, 15-13, 15-10 |
| 1994 | Ohio Northern def. Kalamazoo 4-15, 15-8, 13-15, 15-13, 15-10 |
| 1995 | Ohio Northern def. Calvin 15-10, 12-15, 6-15, 15-9, 15-9 |
| John Carroll, Ohio def. Kalamazoo 15-7, 8-15, 13-15, 15-7, 15-7 | |
| 1997 | Calvin def. Muskingum, Ohio 15-9, 15-8, 16-14 |
| Ohio Northern def. Hope 11-15, 13-15, 15-8, 15-6, 16-14 | |
| Calvin def. Wittenberg, Ohio 13-15, 5-15, 15-13, 15-10, 15-10 | |
| Ohio Northern def. Calvin 15-6, 18-16, 15-7 | |
| 1998 | Hope def. Calvin 11-15, 15-7, 15-5, 16-14 |
| Wittenberg, Ohio def. Hope 7-15, 15-8, 15-3, 13-15, 16-14 | |
| 1999 | Lake Forest, Ill. def. Calvin 15-13, 15-12, 8-15, 15-9 |
2000's
| 2000 | Hope def. DePauw, Ind. 15-12, 2-15, 15-6, 15-8 |
| Wisc-Whitewater def. Hope 15-4, 15-5, 15-7 | |
| 2001 | Carnegie-Mellon, Pa. def. Calvin 30-23, 30-26, 30-23 |
| 2002 | Kalamazoo def. Muskingum, Ohio 30-21, 14-30, 30-21, 30-32, 15-9 |
| Mount St. Joseph, Ohio def. Kalamazoo 30-28, 30-27, 30-25 | |
| 2003 | Alma def. Thomas More, Ky. 30-16, 21-30, 33-31, 30-26 |
| Wittenberg, Ohio def. Alma 30-22, 32-30, 30-15 | |
| 2004 | Alma def. Benedictine, Ill. 30-20, 30-25, 30-26 |
| Wittenberg, Ohio def. Alma 30-21, 31-29, 30-21 | |
| Calvin def. Nebraska Wesleyan 30-19, 30-25, 30-22 | |
| Washington, Mo. def. Calvin 30-26, 24-30, 30-17, 30-21 | |
| 2005 | Calvin def. Hiram, Ohio 30-25, 30-25, 30-20 |
| Calvin def. Millikin, Ill. 30-26, 30-15, 26-30, 30-26 | |
| Wittenberg, Ohio def. Calvin 30-22, 35-33, 30-22 | |
| 2006 | Calvin def. Nazareth, N.Y. 30-12, 30-24, 30-6 |
| Hope def. Ohio Northern 30-24, 31-29, 23-30, 30-28 | |
| Calvin def. Hope 30-23, 30-25, 30-32, 30-21 | |
| Wittenberg def. Calvin 30-26, 30-19, 32-30 | |
| 2007 | Calvin def. Wis.-LaCrosse 26-30, 30-26, 30-20, 30-15 |
| Carthage, Wis. def. Calvin 30-26, 30-23, 30-7 | |
| 2008 | Wis.-Whitewater def. Calvin 25-18, 22-25, 25-18, 25-14 |
| Heidelberg, Ohio def. Hope 25-22, 20-25, 27-29, 25-19, 15-7 | |
| 2009 | Hope def. Lakeland, Wis. 25-17, 25-16, 25-16 |
| Calvin def. Wittenberg, Ohio 25-23, 25-22, 25-21 | |
| Hope def. Calvin 25-18, 25-23, 25-22 | |
| Hope def. Ohio Northern 21-25, 25-14, 25-22, 25-20 | |
| Hope def. Tufts, Mass. 25-17, 25-23, 29-31, 25-18 | |
| Washington, Mo. def. Hope 25-21, 22-25, 15-25, 27-25, 15-12 (National Semifinals) |
2010's
| 2010 | Calvin def. Otterbein, Ohio 25-21, 25-19, 25-14 |
| Hope def. Univ. of Chicago 25-12, 25-22, 25-15 | |
| Calvin def. Heidelberg, Ohio 25-18, 16-25, 25-18, 25-19 | |
| Wittenberg, Ohio def. Hope 25-20, 26-24, 25-17 | |
| Calvin def. Wittenberg, Ohio 25-23, 25-21, 20-25, 25-23 | |
| Calvin def. Mass.-Boston 25-21, 25-10, 17-25, 25-17 | |
| Calvin def. Juniata, Pa. 14-25, 17-25, 25-23, 25-22, 15-12 | |
| Calvin def. Emory, Ga. 25-14, 25-20, 19-25, 25-23 (National Champions) | |
| 2011 | Calvin def. St. Norbert, Wis. 25-14, 25-19, 25-20 |
| Hope def. Otterbein, Ohio 25-21, 25-22, 25-16 | |
| Calvin def. Hope 30-28, 25-15, 25-20 | |
| Wittenberg, Ohio def. Calvin 25-18, 19-25, 25-18, 25-10 | |
| 2012 | Calvin def. Heidelberg, Ohio 25-15, 25-13, 25-17 |
| Hope def. Otterbein, Ohio 25-22, 25-21, 25-22 | |
| Calvin def. Mount Union, Ohio 25-12, 23-25, 25-21, 24-26, 15-6 | |
| Wittenberg, Ohio def. Hope 25-22, 26-24, 25-22 | |
| Calvin def. Wittenberg, Ohio 23-25, 25-18, 23-25, 26-24, 15-12 | |
| Calvin def. Puget Sound, Wash. 25-22, 23-25, 25-15, 25-10 | |
| Calvin def. Christopher Newport, Va. 25-19, 25-21, 23-25, 25-16 | |
| St. Thomas, Minn. def. Calvin 13-25, 17-25, 25-19, 25-16, 15-9 (2nd place nationally) | |
| 2013 | Calvin def. Penn State-Behrend 25-4, 25-15, 25-8 |
| Hope def. Webster, Mo. 25-21, 25-13, 25-17 | |
| Calvin def. Mount Union, Ohio 25-11, 23-25, 25-20, 23-25, 15-8 | |
| Hope def. Otterbein, Ohio 20-25, 25-15, 25-21, 25-22 | |
| Calvin def. Wittenberg, Ohio, 25-19, 25-22, 23-25, 24-26, 15-9 | |
| Hope def. Elmhurst, Ill. 24-26, 25-20, 25-14, 25-15 | |
| Calvin def. Mass.-Boston 25-23, 25-13, 24-26, 25-18 | |
| Wis.-Stevens Point def. Hope 25-22, 25-18, 25-18 | |
| Calvin def. Emory, Ga. 25-17, 25-21, 25-22 | |
| Calvin def. California Lutheran 20-25, 12-25, 25-22, 25-17, 20-18 (National Champions) | |
| 2014 | Calvin def. Wis.-Oshkosh 25-23, 25-22, 25-13 |
| Hope def. Franklin & Marshall, Pa. 25-19, 25-22, 25-20 | |
| Calvin def. Elmhurst, Ill. 25-22, 25-14, 25-27, 25-21 | |
| Hope def. Juniata, Pa. 21-25, 25-27, 25-20, 25-14, 15-8 | |
| Calvin def. Carthage, Wis. 26-24, 21-25, 25-20, 25-13 | |
| Hope def. Wittenberg, Ohio 16-25, 19-25, 25-16, 25-23, 15-13 | |
| Calvin def. Christopher Newport, Va. 25-21, 25-15, 22-25, 25-16 | |
| Hope def. Clarkson, N.Y. 25-16, 25-21, 25-20 | |
| Hope def. Calvin 28-26, 25-18, 25-14 | |
| Hope def. Emory, Ga. 21-25, 25-21, 25-22, 24-26, 15-8 (National Champions) | |
| 2015 | Bethel, Minn. def. Hope 25-23, 25-20, 25-20 |
| Calvin def. Cornell, Iowa 25-18, 25-22, 25-21 | |
| Calvin def. UW-Stevens Point 26-24, 25-12, 25-18 | |
| Carthage, Wisc. def. Calvin 25-27, 25-17, 25-14, 25-15 | |
| 2016 | Elmhurst def. Hope 28-26, 25-22, 25-20 |
| Calvin def. Pitt-Bradford 25-10, 25-14, 25-17 | |
| Calvin def. DePauw, Ind. 25-15, 25-18, 25-23 | |
| Calvin def. Millikin, Ill. 25-18, 25-18, 21-25, 25-14 | |
| Calvin def. Emory, Ga. 25-17, 19-25, 25-24, 25-21, 15-9 | |
| Calvin def. Northwestern, Minn. 28-26, 25-18, 25-17 | |
| Calvin def. Washington, Mo. 25-21, 25-21, 25-21 (National Champions) | |
| 2017 | Calvin def. Washington, Mo. 25-16, 25-15, 20-25, 23-25, 16-4 |
| Calvin def. Millikin, Ill. 25-17, 25-23, 15-17 | |
| Calvin def. Carthage 25-16, 25-17, 21-25, 19-25, 15-9 | |
| Calvin def. Johnson & Wales 25-21, 25-19, 26-24 | |
| Wittenberg def. Calvin 25-19, 25-20, 25-17 |
