An annual scholar athlete award instituted in 2007 to honor of Karen Caine, former long-term women's tennis coach at Adrian College.
| 2007 | Holly Kimball, Trine |
| 2008 | Lindsey Eshelman, Adrian |
| 2009 | Amber Crosby, Trine |
| 2010 | Rachel Strikwerda, Calvin |
| 2011 | Melissa Oosterhouse, Calvin |
| 2012 | Kelsey Hassevoort, Kalamazoo |
| 2013 | Leah LaBarge, Hope |
| 2014 | Mallory Smith, Hope |
| 2015 | Carli Capestany, Hope |
| 2016 | Andrew Fetters, Saint Mary's |
| 2017 | Claire Spoelhoff, Calvin |
| 2018 | Alex Oswalt, Kalamazoo |
| 2019 | Taylor LaBarge, Hope |
| 2020 | Claire Hallock, Hope |
| 2021 | Bailey Chorney, Hope |
| 2022 | Ashley Spirrison, Trine |
| 2023 | Sophie Zhuang, Kalamazoo |
