Updated through 2017

1990
First Round
Adrian 4, Albion 0
Hope 1, Alma 0
Calvin 10, Olivet 0
Second Round
Kalamazoo 4, Adrian 1
Calvin 3, Hope 1
Alma 2, Olivet 1 (shootout)
Third Round
5th place - Albion 2, Alma 1 (shootout)
3rd place - Adrian 2, Hope 1
Championship - Kalamazoo 1, Calvin 0

1998
First Round
Kalamazoo 18, Adrian 0
Calvin 4, Alma 0
Olivet 6, Saint Mary's 1
Hope 2, Albion 1
Semi-Finals
Kalamazoo 2, Hope 0
Olivet 2, Calvin 0
Championship
Olivet 5, Kalamazoo 3 (ot)

1999
First Round
Olivet 3, Saint Mary's 0
Hope 2, Albion 0
Semi-Finals
Calvin 5, Olivet 1
Kalamazoo 5, Hope 0
Championship
Kalamazoo 2, Calvin 0

Note: The league tournament was discontinued
from 2000 through 2005.

2006
First Round
Calvin 4, Alma 0
Kalamazoo 0, Saint Mary's 0 (Kalamazoo won shootout 4-3)
Albion 2, Olivet 1
Hope 5, Adrian 0
Semi-Finals
Calvin 3, Kalamazoo 0
Hope 1, Albion 0
Championship
Calvin 3, Hope 1

2007
First Round
Calvin 3, Olivet 1
Kalamazoo 3, Adrian 1
Albion 2, Alma 0
Hope 1, Saint Mary's 0
Semi-finals
Calvin 5, Hope 1
Albion 2, Kalamazoo 0
Championship
Albion 0, Calvin 0 (Albion won shootout 3-2)

2008
First Round
Calvin 6, Saint Mary's 0
Hope 2, Kalamazoo 0
Adrian 0, Albion 0 (Adrian won shootout 4-3)
Alma 1, Olivet 1 (Alma won shootout 4-3)
Semi-finals
Calvin 4, Adrian 0
Alma 2, Hope 1, 2ot
Championship
Calvin 3, Alma 0

2009
First Round
Albion 1, Adrian 0 (ot)
Kalamazoo 1, Hope 0
Semi-Finals
Albion 0, Alma 0 (Albion won shootout 3-2)
Kalamazoo 0 Calvin 0 (Kalamazoo won shootout 3-1)
Championship
Albion 0, Kalamazoo 0 (Albion won shootout 5-4)

2010
First Round
Adrian 2, Olivet 0
Kalamazoo 3, Albion 0
Semi-Finals
Alma 2, Adrian 0
Calvin 2, Kalamazoo 1
Championship
Calvin 3, Alma 1

2011
Semi-Finals
Adrian 3, Hope 1
Alma 2, Kalamazoo 1
Championship
Alma 1, Adrian 0

2012
Semi-Finals
Calvin 1, Adrian 0
Hope 3, Alma 2
Championship
Calvin 2, Hope 1 (ot)

2013
Semi-Finals
Calvin 3, Adrian 0
Hope 1, Alma 0
Championship
Calvin 2, Hope 0

2014
Semi-Finals
Hope 2, Albion 1
Kalamazoo 5, Alma 1
Championship
Hope 0, Kalamazoo 0 (Hope won shootout 5-4)

2015
Semi-Finals
Hope 2, Kalamazoo 0
Calvin 2, Olivet 0
Championship
Calvin 3, Hope 0

2016
Semi-Finals
Kalamazoo 1, Alma 1 (Kalamazoo won shootout 3-2)
Hope 4, Calvin 0
Championship
Hope 4, Alma 2

2017
Semi-Finals
Olivet 0, Adrian 0 (Olivet won shootout 5-4)
Hope 1, Calvin 0
Championship
Hope 2, Olivet 1