Wrestling was an MIAA-sponsored sport from 1969 to 1984. It was re-instated for the 2018-19 academic year.

1960's

1969
Craig Cossey, AB
Bill Ellenburg, AD
Steve Fugaban, AD
Doug Koval, AD
Gary Kresge, AB
Dennis Mateyka. AD
Steve Myers, K
Steve Rulewicz, AD
Dan VanBlaricom, AD
Dick Vliem, C

1970's

1970
Steve Benedict, AD
Craig Cossey, AB
Steve Fugaban, AD
Bob Knox, AD
Gary Kresge, AB
Ken Meinschein, AB
Steve Myers, K
Karl Nadolsky, HO
Steve Rulewicz, AD
Dick Vleim, C

1971
Larry Bridgewater, O
Neal Fuchs, AD
Steve Fugaban, AD
Rick Hine, HO
Will Jones, O
Ken Meinschein, AB
Andy Muth, K
Karl Nadolsky, HO
Mike Selleck, AD
Rick Vanderlind, HO

1972
Dennis Bishop, K
Kevin Boerman, HO
Larry Boyer, O
Dave Elliott, O
Steve Felder, O
Phil Marsh, K
Steve Myers, K
Mike Selleck, AD
Randy Smith, AB
Rick Vanderlind, HO

1973
Ron Bates, O
Dennis Bishop, K
Dave Elliott, O
Steve Felder, O
Ted Miller, AB
Bob Shegog, O
Randy Smith, AB
Tom TenBrink, C
Rick Vanderlind, HO
Steve Zuhl, K

1974
Tom Barkes, HO
Ron Bates, O
Carl Connin, O
Dave Elliott, O
Joe Gibbs, O
Paul Holdren, AB
Lou Stravroplus, AD
Tom TenBrink, C
Scott Yerrick, C
Steve Zuhl, K

1975
Tom Barkes, HO
Ron Bates, O
Dennis Bishop, K
Joe Gibbs, O
Dave Lange, O
Steve Quaderer, AM
Lou Stravoplus, AD
Tom TenBrink, C
Dave Vibber, AM
Steve Zuhl, K

1976
Ron Bates, O
Dennis Bishop, K
Joe Gibbs, O
Carl Goetzinger, AM
Dave Fleet, O
Hugh Griffith, O
Lou Stravoplus, AD
Jim Pershing, AM
Dave Vibber, AM
Steve Zuhl, K

1977
Mark Clem, O
Steve Crooks, K
Dave Firlick, O
Dave Fleet, O
Joe Gibbs, O
Steve Hill, O
Dave Lange, O
Dan Matthews, AD
Ron Stites, O
Lou Stravoplus, AD

1978
Jim Burgie, O
Pete Charlton, K
Mark Clem, O
John Gringer, O
Bill Malnight, O
Tim Miller, O
Steve Quaderer, AM
Brad Robinson, O
Pete Schaibly, AM
Neil Tuomi, AM

1979
Jim Bicknell, AD
Jim Burgie, O
Steve Crooks, K
Chris Davis, K
Mark Holdren, O
Tim Mallett, K
Tim Miller, O
Mike Munyan, AM
Ken Nagy, O
Mike Sutton, HO

1980's

1980
Gary Adams, AM
Steve Crooks, K
Chris Davis, K
Mark Holdren, O
Chris Kellogg, K
Tim Mallett, K
Tim Miller, O
Clair Rowland, AB
Tom Welke, K
Wendell White, O

1981
Gary Adams, AM
Andy Beachnau, AM
Dan Coon, AM
Tom Kool, C
Chris Miller, AM
Rich Ringer, K
Jeff Soper, AM
Neil Tuomi, AM
Wendell White, O
Scott Yates, K

1982
Dan Coon, AM
Chris Davis, K
Sam Hargrove, O
Mark Helms, AM
Bob Kintz, O
Mike Kreiner, AM
Chris Miller, AM
Dan Pantaleo, O
Dayl Stout, K
Eugene Yzquierdo, AM

1983
Gary Adams, AM
Mike Conway, AM
Dan Coon, AM
Rex Hart, AM
Sam Hargrove, O
Greg Hatcher, AM
Dave Labrecque, O
Chris Miller, AM
Dan Pantaleo, O
Keith Root, O

1984
Keith DeVries, HO
Rich Goodman, O
Sam Hargrove, O
Rex Hart, AM
Bob Kintz, O
Dave Labrecque, O
Chris Miller, AM
Dan Pantaleo, O
Mike Pantaleo, O
Dale Sharrod, O