2013 Stacey Birlson, Adrian (offense)
          Grace Garrett, Trine (defense) 

2014 Hannah Early, Adrian (offense)
          Grace Garrett, Trine (defense)

2015 Mackenzie Novak, Albion (offense)
          Victoria Della Pia, Albion (defense)

2016 Katie Koolwick, Albion (offense)
          Katie Johnson, Kalamazoo (defense)
          Hannah VanAlst, Hope (rookie)

2017 Mary Singler, Saint Mary's (offense)
          Emily Cefaratti, Calvin (defense)
          Mary Singler, Saint Mary's (rookie)

2018 Kelly Pepper, Calvin (offense)
          Taylor Nelson, Albion (defense)
          Erin Doyle, Saint Mary's (rookie)