Established in 2010
| 2010 | Mary Kate Boyce, Saint Mary's |
| 2011 | Lauren Campbell, Olivet |
| 2012 | Charlotte Park, Hope |
| 2013 | Alexi Bown, Saint Mary's |
| 2014 | Morgan Henry, Alma |
| 2015 | Celine McClimans, Albion |
| 2016 | Emily Bristow, Adrian |
| 2017 | Megan Moco, Albion |
| 2018 | Nicole VanderYacht, Calvin |
| 2019 | Brooke Symons, Adrian |
| Spring 2021* | Abby Meder, Hope |
| 2021 | Emma Dykhouse, Calvin |
| 2022 | Jericha Scharphorn, Calvin |
* Fall 2020 season played in spring of 2021 due to COVID-19.
