| 1993* | Lisa Stover, Hope, 23rd |
| Cathy Curley, Alma, 30th | |
| 1994* | Lisa Stover, Hope, 5th (All-American) |
| Karen Baird, Adrian, 9th (All-American) | |
| Cathy Curley, Alma, 15th | |
| 1995* | Melissa Korte, Albion, 15th |
| Cathy Curley, Alma, 22nd | |
| Tracy Gutek, Adrian, 24th | |
| Kristen Cline, Hope, 26th | |
| 1997 | Nancy Kennedy, Hope, 48th |
| 1998 | Ellen Colenbrander, Hope, 7th (All-American) |
| 1999 | Ellen Colenbrander, Hope, 19th |
|
2000
|
Ellen Colenbrander, Hope, 8th (All-American) |
| 2001 | Lacey Wicksall, Hope, 15th |
| Stacy Chapman, Albion, 40th | |
| 2002 | Courtney Rheinhardt, Alma, 9th (All-American) |
| Lacey Wicksall, Hope, 22nd | |
| 2003 | Saint Mary's, 4th as a team |
| Stefanie Simmerman, Saint Mary's, 1st (Division III Medalist) | |
| Megan Mattia, Saint Mary's, 14th | |
| Emily Colenbrander, Hope, 31st | |
| Julia Adams, Saint Mary's, 37th | |
| Chrissy Dunham, Saint Mary's, 47th | |
| Liz Hanlon, Saint Mary's, 54th | |
| 2004 | Saint Mary's, 8th as a team |
| Stefanie Simmerman, Saint Mary's, 12th | |
| Julia Adams, Saint Mary's, 40th | |
| Lacey Wicksall, Hope, 44th | |
| Liz Hanlon, Saint Mary's, 50th | |
| Chrissy Dunham, Saint Mary's, 52nd | |
| Nicole Bellino, Saint Mary's, 59th | |
| 2005 | Saint Mary's, 6th as a team |
| Julia Adams, Saint Mary's, 9th (All-American) | |
| Stefanie Simmerman, Saint Mary's, 12th | |
| Megan Mattia, Saint Mary's, 26th | |
| Chrissy Dunham, Saint Mary's, 53rd | |
| Nicole Bellino, Saint Mary's, 57th | |
| 2006 | Megan Mattia, Saint Mary's, 18th |
| Elizabeth Kreger, Albion, 32nd | |
| 2007 | Olivet, 8th as a team |
| Kristy Latimer, Olivet, 30th | |
| Lindsay Pipkin, Olivet, 35th | |
| Trisha McKim, Olivet, 58th | |
| Megan Rimmel, Olivet, 71st | |
| Stephanie Nicolai, Olivet, 100th | |
| 2008 | Olivet, 11th as a team |
| Trisha McKim, Olivet, 31st | |
| Lindsay Pipkin, Olivet, 50th | |
| Amanda Sanders, Olivet, 50th | |
| Megan Rimmel, Olivet, 58th | |
| Amber Conrad, Olivet, 73rd | |
| 2009 | Saint Mary's 10th as a team |
| Emily Gore, Saint Mary's, 17th | |
| Natalie Matuszak, Saint Mary's, 36th | |
| Mary Kate Boyce, Saint Mary's, 61st | |
| Rosie O'Connor, Saint Mary's, 64th | |
| Meredith Fantom, Saint Mary's, 82nd | |
| Olivet, tied 11th as a team | |
| Lindsay Pipkin, Olivet, 24th | |
| Megan Rimmel, Olivet, 31st | |
| Amber Conrad, Olivet, 36th | |
| Katie Misko, Olivet, 72nd | |
| Lauren Campbell, Olivet, 79th | |
| 2010 | Saint Mary's, 4th as a team |
| Natalie Matuszak, Saint Mary's, 3rd (All-American) | |
| Mary Kate Boyce, Saint Mary's, 9th (All-American) | |
| Rosie O'Connor, Saint Mary's, 68th | |
| Perri Hamma, Saint Mary's, 75th | |
| Christine Brown, Saint Mary's, 90th | |
| Olivet, 11th as a team | |
| Lauren Campbell, Olivet, 24th | |
| Amber Conrad, Olivet, 36th | |
| Megan Rimmel, Olivet, 40th | |
| Abby Wheeler, Olivet, 87th | |
| 2011 | Saint Mary's, 4th as a team |
| Mary Kate Boyce, Saint Mary's, 9th (All-American) | |
| Marin Beagley, Saint Mary's, 14th | |
| Doyle O'Brien, Saint Mary's, 31st | |
| Natalie Matuszak, Saint Mary's, 44th | |
| Rosie O'Connor, Saint Mary's, 59th | |
| Olivet, tied 10th as a team | |
| Amber Conrad, Olivet, 19th | |
| Lauren Campbell, Olivet, 26th | |
| Abby Wheeler, Olivet, 59th | |
| Adrienne Jones, Olivet, 63rd | |
| Theresa Damico, Olivet, 86th | |
| 2012 | Saint Mary's, 15th as a team |
| Doyle O'Brien, Saint Mary's, 6th (All-American) | |
| Janice Heffernan, Saint Mary's, 61st | |
| Natalie Matuszak, Saint Mary's, 80th | |
| Christine Brown, Saint Mary's, 84th | |
| Paige Pollak, Saint Mary's, 85th | |
| 2013 | Olivet, 13th as a team |
| Adrienne Plourde, Olivet, 45th | |
| Theresa Damico, Olivet, 58th | |
| Brooke Kastamo, Olivet, 75th | |
| Ashley Stark, Olivet, 82nd | |
| Casey Lamp, Olivet, 94th | |
| 2014 | Olivet, 11th as a team |
| Theresa Damico, Olivet, 27th | |
| Brooke Kastamo, Olivet, 51st | |
| Adrienne Plourde, Olivet, 52nd | |
| Casey Lamp, Olivet, 54th | |
| Ashley Stark, Olivet, 61st | |
| 2015 | Hope, 11th as a team |
| Megan Klintworth, Hope, T30th | |
| Britni Gielow, Hope, T42nd | |
| Nicole Meyer, Hope, T42nd | |
| Montana Leep, Hope, T61st | |
| Morgan Leep, Hope, T72nd | |
| 2016 | Hope, 10th as a team |
| Britni Gielow, Hope, 7th | |
| Nicole Meyer, Hope, T31st | |
| Megan Klintworth, Hope, T41st | |
| Morgan Leep, Hope, 75th | |
| Megan Wierenga, Hope, T86th | |
| 2017 | Hope, 11th as a team |
| Nicole Meyer, Hope, T43rd | |
| Megan Wierenga, Hope, T43rd | |
| Megan Klintworth, Hope, T46th | |
| Dominique Molinaro, Hope, T49th | |
| Britni Gielow, Hope, 74th | |
