| 1991 | Lisa Stover, Hope |
| 1992 | Lisa Stover, Hope |
| 1993 | Lisa Stover, Hope |
| 1994 | Tracy Gutek, Adrian |
| 1995 | Maggie Taylor, Alma |
| 1996 | Ellen Colenbrander, Hope |
| 1997 | Jenny Peters, Alma |
| 1998 | Ellen Colenbrander, Hope |
| 1999 | Ellen Colenbrander, Hope |
| 2000 | Lacey Wicksall, Hope |
| 2001 | Courtney Rheinhardt, Alma |
| 2002 | Courtney Rheinhardt, Alma |
| 2003 | Courtney Rheinhardt, Alma |
| Stefanie Simmerman, Saint Mary's | |
| 2004 | Julia Adams, Saint Mary's |
| 2005 | Megan Mattia, Saint Mary's |
| 2006 | Kristy Latimer, Olivet |
| 2007 | Katie O'Brien, Saint Mary's |
| 2008 | Rosie O'Connor, Saint Mary's |
| 2009 | Martyna Mierzwa, Saint Mary's |
| 2010 | Mary Kate Boyce, Saint Mary's |
| 2011 | Lauren Campbell, Olivet |
| 2012 | Theresa Damico, Olivet |
| 2013 | Adrienne Plourde, Olivet |
| 2014 | Megan Klintworth, Hope |
| 2015 | Sammie Averill, Saint Mary's |
| 2016 | Megan Klintworth, Hope |
| 2017 | Megan Klintworth, Hope |
Sportsmanship Award
Established in 2010
| 2010 | Mary Kate Boyce, Saint Mary's |
| 2011 | Lauren Campbell, Olivet |
| 2012 | Charlotte Park, Hope |
| 2013 | Alexi Bown, Saint Mary's |
| 2014 | Morgan Henry, Alma |
| 2015 | Celine McClimans, Albion |
| 2016 | Emily Bristow, Adrian |
| 2017 | Megan Moco, Albion |
