1980's
| 1985 | Wisc.-Whitewater 85, Alma 70 (Regional) | |
| Alma 78, Carroll, Wisc. 72 (Regional) | ||
| 1986 | Wisc.-Whitewater 71, Alma 65 (Regional) | |
| Alma 74, Susquehanna, Pa. 61 (Regional) | ||
| 1987 | Alma 67, Wisc.-Whitewater 48 (Regional) | |
| Wisc.-Stevens Point 75, Alma 58 (Regional) | ||
| 1988 | Wisc.-LaCrosse 68, Calvin 65 (Regional) | |
| Calvin 54, Wisc.-River Falls 47 (Regional) | ||
| 1989 | Wisc.-Eau Claire 68, Alma 63 (Regional) | |
| Alma 79, St. Norbert, Wisc. 69 (Regional) |
1990's
| 1990 | Hope 73, St. Benedict, Minn. 60 (Regional) | |
| Hope 68, Wisc.-Oshkosh 67 (Regional) | ||
| Hope 85, Buena Vista, Iowa 79 (ot) (Quarterfinals) | ||
| Hope 75, Centre, Ky. 62 (Semifinals) | ||
| Hope 65, St. John Fisher, N.Y. 63 (Championship game) | ||
| 1991 | Adrian 57, Calvin 50 (First Round) | |
| Concordia-Moorhead, Minn., 100, Adrian 75 (Regional) | ||
| 1992 | Alma 92, Adrian 77 (First Round) | |
| Alma 69, Roanoke, Va. 60 (Sectional) | ||
| Alma 83, Wisc.-Eau Claire 73 (Sectional) | ||
| Alma 81, Luther, Iowa 80 (Semifinals) | ||
| Alma 79, Moravian, Pa. 75 (Championship game) | ||
| 1993 | Wisc.-Whitewater 77, Calvin 69 | |
| 1994 | Alma 74, Franklin, Ind. 59 (First Round) | |
| Wisc.-Oshkosh 63, Alma 59 (Second Round) | ||
| 1995 | Wisc.-Oshkosh 68, Hope 44 (First Round) | |
| 1996 | Calvin 60, Ripon, Wisc. 50 (First Round) | |
| Beloit, Wisc. 47, Alma 44 (First Round) | ||
| Wisc.-Eau Claire 68, Calvin 47 (Second Round) | ||
| 1997 | Alma 66, Kenyon, Ohio 59 (First Round) | |
| Calvin 58, Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 55 (First Round) | ||
| Defiance, Ohio 85, Alma 72 (Second Round) | ||
| Capital, Ohio 66, Calvin 43 (Second Round) | ||
| 1998 | Calvin 56, Wittenberg, Ohio 47 (First Round) | |
| Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 75, Hope 71 (First Round) | ||
| Mount Union, Ohio 57, Calvin 56 (Second Round) | ||
| 1999 | Capital, Ohio 86, Hope 75 (First Round) | |
| Calvin 60, Ohio Wesleyan 50 (First Round) | ||
| Calvin 75, Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 67 (Second Round) | ||
| Capital, Ohio 82, Defiance 72 (Second Round) | ||
| Wisc.-Oshkosh 61, Calvin 59 (Sectional) |
2000's
| 2000 | Calvin 68, Lake Forest, Ill. 42 (First Round) |
| Calvin 64, Capital, Ohio 63 (Second Round) | |
| Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 76, Calvin 62 (2ot) (Sectional) | |
| 2001 | Ohio Wesleyan 72, Hope 71 (First Round) |
| 2002 | Hope 87, Thomas More, Ky. 76 (Second Round) |
| Wilmington, Ohio 89, Hope 81 (Sectional) | |
| 2003 | Hope 75, Mount St. Joseph, Ohio 63 (First Round) |
| Hope 71, Washington & Jefferson, Pa. 60 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 77, Wilmington, Ohio 73 (Sectional) | |
| Wisc.-Eau Claire 74, Hope 56 (Sectional) | |
| 2004 | Wilmington, Ohio 66, Albion 62 (First Round) |
| 2005 | Calvin 74, Franklin, Ind. 60 (First Round) |
| Calvin 72, DePauw, Ind. 63 (Second Round) | |
| Albion 63, Denison, Ohio 44 (Second Round) | |
| Calvin 64, Albion 56 (Sectional) | |
| Millikin, Ill. 63, Calvin 56 (Sectional) | |
| 2006 | Carroll, Wisc. 64, Calvin 57 (First Round) |
| Hope 72, Denison, Ohio 51 (First Round) | |
| Hope 75, Capital, Ohio 56 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 92, Washington, Mo. 89 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 76, DePauw, Ind. 60 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 59, Scranton, Pa. 56 (Semifinals) | |
| Hope 69, Southern Maine 56 (Championship game) | |
| 2007 | Calvin 53, Thomas More, Ky. 38 (First Round) |
| Denison, Ohio 82, Hope 66 (First Round) | |
| Calvin 73, Wilmington, Ohio 67 (Second Round) | |
| Calvin 60, Southern Maine 56 (Sectional) | |
| DePauw, Ind. 74, Calvin 61 (Sectional) | |
| 2008 | Hope 76, Juniata, Pa. 47 (First Round) |
| Hope 68, Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 48 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 47, George Fox, Ore. 40 (Sectional) | |
| Howard Payne, Tex. 53, Hope 49 (Sectional) | |
| 2009 | Hope 87, Washington & Jefferson, Pa. 64 (First Round) |
| Hope 69, Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 53 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 67, Thomas More, Ky. 51 (Sectional) | |
| George Fox, Ore. 58, Hope 46 (Sectional) |
2010's
| 2010 | Hope 68, Denison, Ohio 40 (First Round) |
| St. Norbert, Wis. 78, Calvin 67 (First Round) | |
| Hope 68, DePauw, Ind. 54 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 53, Marymount, Va. 46 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 71, Wis.-Stevens Point 64 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 76, Rochester, N.Y. 65 (Semifinals) | |
| Washington, Mo. 65, Hope 59 (Championship Game) | |
| 2011 | Calvin 73, LaRoche, Pa. 37 (First Round) |
| Hope 77, DePauw, Ind. 65 (First Round) | |
| Univ. of Chicago 67, Calvin 62 (Second Round) | |
| Washington, Mo. 56, Hope 52 (Second Round) | |
| 2012 | Calvin 59, Wisconsin Lutheran 47 (First Round) |
| Calvin 76, Wis.-Stevens Point 71 (Second Round) | |
| Calvin 68, Univ. of Chicago 50 (Sectional) | |
| St. Thomas, Minn. 83, Calvin 72 (ot) (Sectional) | |
| 2013 | Hope 64, Wheaton, Ill. 37 (First Round) |
| St. Thomas, Minn. 64, Calvin 62 (First Round) | |
| Hope 63, Ohio Northern 48 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 71, St. Thomas, Minn. 61 (Sectional) | |
| Wis.-Whitewater 65, Hope 60 (Sectional) | |
| 2014 | Hope 60, Wisconsin Lutheran 54 (First Round) |
| Carthage, Wis. 72, Hope 67 (Second Round) | |
| 2015 | Hope 75, Bethel, Minn. 63 (First Round) |
| Calvin 80, Baldwin Wallace, Ohio 66 (First Round) | |
| Hope 72, Wisconsin Lutheran 47 (Second Round) | |
| Calvin 91, Wis.-Oshkosh 71 (Second Round) | |
| St. Thomas, Minn. 55, Hope 47 (Sectional Semifinals) | |
| Calvin 71, DePauw, Ind. 62 (Sectional Semifinals) | |
| George Fox, Ore. 78, Calvin 63 (Sectional Finals) | |
| 2016 | Carnegie Mellon 73, Hope 72 (First Round) |
| 2017 | Hope 78, UW-Whitewater 71 (First Round) |
| Trine 63, Illinois Wesleyan 56 (First Round) | |
| UW-Oshkosh 63, Calvin 55 (First Round) | |
| Hope 74, Thomas More, Ky. 67 (Second Round) | |
| Ohio Northern 55, Trine 48 (Second Round) | |
| Christopher Newport, Va. 79, Hope 74 (Sectional Semifinals) | |
| 2018 | Trine 65, DePauw, Ind. 50 (First Round) |
| Hope 75, Cornell, Iowa 50 (First Round) | |
| Trine 79, Illinois Wesleyan 70 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 85, Washington, Mo. 69 (Second Round) | |
| Wartburg, Iowa 78, Trine 54 (Sectional Semifinals) | |
| Hope 68, Christopher Newport, Va. 64 (Sectional Semifinals) | |
| Thomas More, Ky. 72, Hope 57 (Sectinal Finals) |
