1983  

Calvin 2, Wis.-Whitewater 0 (Regional)
North Central, Ill. 2, Calvin 0 (Regional)
Calvin 9, North Central, Ill. 0 (Regional)
North Central, Ill. 1, Calvin 0 (Regional)

1984

Ohio Northern 6, Calvin 5 (Regional)
Calvin 2, Allegheny, Pa. 1 (Regional)
Calvin 2, Ohio Northern 1, 8 innings (Regional)
Buena Vista, Iowa 1, Calvin 0 (Nationals)
Wis.-Whitewater 11, Calvin 0 (Nationals)

1985

California-San Diego 6, Calvin 1 (Regional)
Allegheny, Pa. 1, Calvin 0 (Regional)

1987

Calvin 3, Wis.-Oshkosh 0 (Regional)
Calvin 2, Wis.-Whitewater 0 (Regional)
Wis.-Whitewater 10, Calvin 3 (Regional)
Wis.-Whitewater 6, Calvin 1 (Regional)

1989

Calvin 2, North Central, Ill. 1 (Regional)
Calvin 2, California-San Diego 0 (Regional)
Calvin 3, California-San Diego 1 (Regional)
Buena Vista, Iowa 5, Calvin 1 (Nationals)
Trenton State, N.J. 5, Calvin 3 (Nationals)

1990   

Calvin 2, Adrian 1 (Regional)
Millikin, Ill. 6, Adrian 1 (Regional)
Calvin 4, Millikin, Ill. 0 (Regional)
Calvin 4, Millikin, Ill. 3 (Regional)
Calvin 6, Allegheny, Pa. 0 (Nationals)
Trenton State, N.J. 3, Calvin 0 (Nationals)
Eastern Connecticut 8, Calvin 1 (Nationals)

1991

Adrian 4, Aurora, Ill. 3 (Regional)
Hope 1, Aurora, Ill. 0 (Regional)
Hope 3, Adrian 1, 9 innings (Regional)
Hope 7, Adrian 3 (Regional)
Hope 5, Capital, Ohio 0 (Nationals)
Trenton State, N.J. 8, Hope 0 (Nationals)
Hope 2, Luther, Iowa 0 (Nationals)
Eastern Connecticut 3, Hope 2 (Nationals, 3rd place)

1992

Central, Iowa 1, Hope 0 (Regional)
Hope 2, Illinois Benedictine 0 (Regional)
Hope 8, Central, Iowa 3 (Regional)
Illinois Benedictine 2, Hope 1 (Regional)

1993

Adrian 9, Aurora, Ill. 8 (Regional)
Illinois Benedictine 5, Adrian 3 (Regional)
Illinois Benedictine 7, Adrian 0 (Regional)

1994

Alma 4, Millikin, Ill. 2 (Regional)
Alma 4, Illinois Benedictine 3 (Regional)
Alma 7, Millikin, Ill. 6 (Regional)
Central, Iowa 4, Alma 3, 16 innings (Nationals)
Rowan, N.J. 6, Alma 1 (Nationals)

1995

Hope 6, Coe, Iowa 4 (Regional)
Hope 4, Calvin 3, 10 innings (Regional)
Hope 6, Coe, Iowa 5(Regional)
Calvin 3, Alma 2 (Regional)
Coe, Iowa 6, Alma 4 (Regional)
Central, Iowa 2, Hope 1, 9 innings (Nationals)
Allegheny, Pa. 8, Hope 2 (Nationals)

1996

Hope 4, Calvin 3 (Regional)
Calvin 3, Illinois Wesleyan 0 (Regional)
Chapman, Calif. 1, Hope 0 (Regional)
Calvin 1, Hope 0 (Regional)
Chapman, Calif. 6, Calvin 0 (Regional)

1997

Calvin 2, Alma 1, 8 innings (Regional)
Alma 10, Wisconsin-Oshkosh 3 (Regional)
Capital, Ohio 4, Alma 3 (Regional)
Calvin 9, Capital, Ohio 6, 9 innings (Regional)
Calvin 7, Capital, Ohio 6, 8 innings (Regional)
College of New Jersey 8, Calvin 0 (Nationals)
Wheaton, Mass. 10, Calvin 7 (Nationals)

1998

Calvin 8, Southern Maine 0 (Regional)
Alma 3, Calvin 0 (Regional)
Alma 3, Mount Union, Ohio 0 (Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 2, Calvin 1(Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 4, Alma 3 (Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 2, Alma 0 (Regional)

1999

Alma 1, Mt. Union 0, Ohio, 9 innings (Regional)
Alma 3, Muskingum, Ohio, 0 (Regional)
Alma 8, Muskingum, Ohio, 0 (Regional)
Wis.-Eau Claire 4, Alma 0 (Nationals)
Alma 4, Ithaca, N.Y. 2 (Nationals)
Alma 4, Rowan, N.J. 1 (Nationals)
Alma 4, Wis.-Eau Claire 3 (Nationals)
Chapman, Calif. 3, Alma 1 (Nationals, 3rd place)

2000   

Alma 8, Wittenberg, Ohio 0 (Regional)
Alma 1, Muskingum, Ohio 0 (Regional)
Alma 6, Muskingum, Ohio 0 (Regional)
Roanoke, Va. 4, Alma 0 (Nationals)
Alma 4, Tufts, Mass. 0 (Nationals)
Alma 3, College of New Jersey 2, 8 innings (Nationals)
Alma 5, Wis.-Eau Claire 0 (Nationals)
Chapman, Calif. 3, Alma 1 (Nationals, 3rd place)

2001

Alma 8, Manchester, Ind. 0 (Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 3, Alma 2 (Regional)
Denison, Ohio 5, Alma 0 (Regional)

2002

Alma 3, Mount St. Joseph, Ohio 0 (Regional)
Capital, Ohio 2, Alma 1 (Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 2, Alma 0 (Regional)

2003

Alma 7, Bethany, W. Va. 0 (Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 2, Alma 1 (Regional)
Alma 7, Cabrini, Pa. 2 (Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 6, Alma 1 (Regional)

2004

Alma 6, Lake Forest Ill. 0 (Regional)
University of Chicago 1, Alma 0 (Regional)
Alma 3, Augustana Ill. 1 (Regional)
Alma 4, University of Chicago 1 (Regional)
Alma 1, University of Chicago 0 (Regional)
Salisbury, Md. 3, Alma 2, 10 innings (Nationals)
Chapman, Calif. 7, Alma 6, 15 innings (Nationals)

2005

Alma 4, North Central, Ill. 3 (Regional)
Alma 2, Aurora, Ill. 1, 13 innings (Regional)
Alma 4, Aurora, Ill. 1 (Regional)
Salisbury, Md. 3, Alma 0 (Nationals)
Alma 1, Williams, Mass. 0 (Nationals)
Ithaca, N.Y. 5, Alma 4 (Nationals)

2006

Hope 5, Augustana 2 (Regional)
Hope 2, Chicago 0 (Regional)
UW-Eau Claire 1, Hope 0 (Regional)
Coe, Iowa 3, Hope 1 (Regional)

2007

Alma 12, Maryville, Tenn. 0, 5 innings (Regional)
DePauw, Ind. 11, Alma 1, 5 innings (Regional)
Anderson, Ind. 2, Alma 1 (Regional)

2008

Washington, Mo. 1, Tri-State 0(Regional)
Wartburg, Iowa 4, Alma 0 (Regional)
Maryville, Mo. 5, Tri-State 1 (Regional)
Coe, Iowa 7, Alma 0 (Regional)

2009

Defiance 1, Trine 0 (Regional)
Ohio Northern 4, Trine 3, 9 innings (Regional)
Thomas More, Ky. 4, Adrian 3, 10 innings (Regional)
Hiram, Ohio 2, Adrian 1 (Regional)
Alma 4, Concordia, Wis. 1 (Regional)
Alma 3, Concordia, Wis. 1 (Regional)
Illinois Wesleyan 6, Alma 3 (Regional)
Coe, Iowa 1, Alma 0 (Regional)

2010   

Carthage, Wis. 4, Alma 0 (Regional)
St. Norbert, Wis. 4, Alma 2 (Regional)
North Central, Ill. 8, Trine 6 (Regional)
Trine 5, Thomas More, Ky. 2 (Regional)
Trine 4, Transylvania, Ky. 0 (Regional)
Washington, Mo. 7, Trine 5 (Regional)

2011   

Ohio Northern 3, Trine 0 (Regional)
Hiram, Ohio 4, Alma 0 (Regional)
Trine 11, D'Youville, N.Y. 0, 6 innings (Regional)
Alma 11, Bethany, W. Va. 0, 6 innings (Regional)
Alma 10, Ohio Northern 6 (Regional)
Trine 6, Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 5 (Regional)
Trine 7, Alma 6 (Regional)
Hiram, Ohio 19, Trine 7, 5 innings (Regional)

2012

  

Trine 6, Geneva, Pa. 5 (Regional)
Alma 6, Denison, Ohio 5 (Regional) 
Trine 6, Univ. of Chicago 1 (Regional)
Ohio Northern 2, Alma 1 (Regional)
Alma 2, John Carroll, Ohio 0 (Regional)
Trine 2, Ohio Northern 0 (Regional)
Alma 3, Univ. of Chicago 1 (Regional)
Ohio Northern 4, Alma 1 (Regional)
Ohio Northern 7, Trine 6 (Regional)
Ohio Northern 7, Trine 5 (Regional)

2013

  

Anderson, Ind. 5, Trine 1 (Regional)
Trine 6, Mount Union, Ohio 4 (Regional)
Trine 12, Capital, Ohio 5 (Regional)
Anderson, Ind. 10, Trine 6 (Regional)

2014

  

Trine 7, Washington & Jefferson, Pa. 1 (Regional)
Muskingum, Ohio 5, Trine 4 (Regional) 
Trine 4, DePauw, Ind. 1 (Regional)
Trine 5, Muskingum, Ohio 4 (Regional)
Trine 13, Muskingum, Ohio 4, 6 innings (Regional)
Trine 6, Emory, Ga. 5, 10 innings (Super Regional)
Trine 6, Emory, Ga. 2 (Super Regional)
Montclair State, N.J. 3, Trine 1 (Nationals)
East Texas Baptist 11, Trine 3, 5 innings (Nationals)

Thomas More, Ky. 3, Trine 2 (Regional)
Hope 5, North Central, Ill. 0 (Regional)
Lake Forest, Ill. 4, Hope 1 (Regional)
Lake Forest, Ill. 2, Hope 0 (Regional)
Alma 1, Illinois Wesleyan 0, 8 inn (Regional)
Alma 2, Simpson, Iowa 1 (Regional)
Trine 4, Thomas More, Ky. 0 (Regional)
DePauw 7, Trine 5 (Regional)
Alma 8, Simpson, Iowa 0 (Regional)
Alma 3, Lake Forest 0 (Super Regional)
Alma 7, Lake Forest, Ill. 1 (Super Regional)
Tufts, Mass. 3, Alma 0 ) (Nationals)
DePauw 5, Alma 4 (Nationals)

2016 

Benedictine, Ill. 2, Alma 1 (Regional)
Alma 9, Wittenberg, Ohio 2 (Regional)
Benedictine, Ill. 6, Alma 0 (Regional)
Trine 5, Greenville, Ill. 3 (Regional)
Trine 3, Wheaton, Ill. 0 (Regional)
Trine 15, Chicago, Ill. 3 (Regional)
St. Thomas, Minn. 9, Trine 5 (Super Regional)
St. Thomas, Minn. 2, Trine 1 (Super Regional)

Trine 12, Greenville, Ill. 1 (5) (Regional)
UW-Whitewater 4, Hope 1 (Regional)
Hope 6, Greenville, Ill. 5 (Regional)
Alma 9, DePauw, Ind. 1 (5) (Regional)
Illinois Wesleyan 4, Alma 3 (Regional)
Trine 6, Hope 3 (Regional)
Alma 3, Otterbein, Ohio 2 (Regional)
Illinois Wesleyan 4, Alma 1 (Regional)
Trine 7, UW-Oshkosh 6 (Super Regional)
Trine 7, UW-Oshkosh 5 (Super Regional)
Amherst, Mass. 4, Trine 3 (8) (Nationals)
Virginia Wesleyan 2, Trine 2 (Nationals)

Calvin 3, Franklin, Ind. 0 (Regional)
Calvin 5, Hope 2 (Regional)
Hope 8, Greenville, Ill. 0 (Regional)
Hope 6, Franklin, Ind. 1 (Regional)
Hope 9, Calvin 6 (Regional)
Hope 2, Calvin 0 (Regional)
Case Western Reserve, Ohio 3, Hope 2 (Super Regional)
Hope 3, Case Western Reserve, Ohio 1 (Super Regional)
Case Western Reserve, Ohio 4, Hope 1 (Super Regional)
Saint Mary's 6, Mt. Aloysius, Pa. 1 (Regional)
Ohio Northern 5, Saint Mary's 0 (Regional)
Case-Western, Ohio 6, Saint Mary's 2 (Regional)
Coe, Iowa 12, Trine 2 (Regional)
Trine 5, Benedictine, Ill. 1 (Regional)
Coe, Iowa 4, Trine 3 (Regional)