| Goals | Years | No. |
| Derek Bylsma, Kalamazoo | 86-89 | 56 |
| Doug DeSmit, Calvin | 80-83 | 49 |
| Joey Barone, Calvin | 88-91 | 48 |
| John Farnese, Albion | 84-87 | 46 |
| Travis Vegter, Calvin | 11-14 | 46 |
| Marc Tirikian, Kalamazoo | 82-85 | 45 |
| Robin Wells, Kalamazoo | 91-94 | 39 |
| Mark Recker, Calvin | 76-79 | 34 |
| Jerry Nyanor, Hope | 84-86 | 34 |
| Ross Bower, Kalamazoo | 99-02 | 34 |
| Assists | Years | No. |
| Mark Recker, Calvin | 76-79 | 31 |
| Doug DeSmit, Calvin | 80-83 | 30 |
| David Dwaihy, Kalamazoo | 98-01 | 30 |
| Joey Barone, Calvin | 88-91 | 28 |
| Jon Beaubien, Kalamazoo | 83-86 | 23 |
| Greg Hartker, Kalamazoo | 90-93 | 22 |
| Matt Keller, Alma | 96-99 | 22 |
| Nick Houdek, Kalamazoo | 02-05 | 22 |
| Mike Arends, Kalamazoo | 91-94 | 21 |
| Marcus Byeman, Calvin | 97-00 | 21 |
| Ross Bower, Kalamazoo | 99-02 | 21 |
| Zach Willis, Calvin | 10-13 | 21 |
| Total Points | Years | Pts. |
| Derek Bylsma, Kalamazoo | 86-89 | 131 |
| Doug DeSmit, Calvin | 80-83 | 128 |
| Joey Barone, Calvin | 88-91 | 124 |
| Travis Vegter, Calvin | 11-14 | 107 |
| John Farnese, Albion | 84-87 | 106 |
| Mark Recker, Calvin | 76-79 | 99 |
| Robin Wells, Kalamazoo | 91-94 | 97 |
| Marc Tirikian, Kalamazoo | 82-85 | 96 |
| Ross Bower, Kalamazoo | 99-02 | 89 |
| Nick Houdek, Kalamazoo | 02-05 | 88 |
