1960's
| 1965 | Dave Tuls, Calvin |
| 1966 | Jim Gittleman, Alma |
| 1967 | Bruce Miller, Albion |
| 1968 | Jerry Knowlton, Alma |
| 1969 | Jim Goodrich, Alma |
1970's
|
1970 |
Bill Schueller, Albion |
| 1971 | Tom Page, Hope |
| 1972 | Rick Lacy, Kalamazoo (Spring) |
| 1972 | Dennis Wahr, Albion (Fall) |
| 1973 | Rick Lacy, Kalamazoo |
| 1974 | Steve Richmond, Albion |
| 1975 | Ted Durdel, Adrian |
| 1976 | Kurt Shader, Albion |
| 1977 | Keith Penoyar, Olivet |
| 1978 | John Kober, Olivet |
| 1979 | Russ Miller, Alma, and Steve Vickrey, Adrian |
1980's
| 1980 | Keith Penoyar, Olivet |
| 1981 | Mike Custer, Adrian |
| 1982 | Ted Kallgren, Alma |
| 1983 | Andy Deutscher, Adrian |
| 1984 | Steve John, Albion |
| 1985 | Tim Smith, Olivet |
| 1986 | Brian Westveer, Hope |
| 1987 | Kevin VandenBerg, Kalamazoo |
| 1988 | Kevin VandenBerg, Kalamazoo |
| 1989 | Magnus Lundblad, Hope |
1990's
| 1990 | Brian Robinette, Olivet |
| 1991 | Brian Robinette, Olivet |
| 1992 | Mike Peddie, Hope |
| 1993 | Brian Robinette, Olivet |
| 1994 | Jason Hartman, Olivet |
| 1995 | Dave Millward, Olivet |
| 1996 | Tony Keim, Olivet |
| 1997 | Mark Raven, Olivet |
| 1998 | Eric Wohlfield, Hope |
| 1999 | Eric Wohlfield, Hope |
2000's
| 2000 | Aaron VandenBerg, Hope |
| 2001 | Eric Wohlfield, Hope |
| 2002 | Justin Spyker, Hope |
| 2003 | Ryan Shedd, Hope |
| 2004 | Tommy Yamaoka, Hope |
| 2005 | Joel Bickel, Tri-State |
| 2006 | Matt Lapham, Hope |
| 2007 | Tommy Yamaoka, Hope |
| 2008 | Steven Strock, Hope |
| 2009 | Steven Strock, Hope |
2010's
| 2010 | Chris Ansel, Hope |
| 2011 | Ben Kuiper, Calvin |
| 2012 | Marty Predmesky, Alma |
| 2013 | Winton Munch, Hope |
| 2014 | Winton Munch, Hope |
| 2015 | Ben VanScoyk, Calvin |
| 2016 | Josh Gibson, Hope |
| 2017 | Josh Gibson, Hope |
Sportsmanship Award
Established in 2007
| 2007 | Evan Kay, Alma |
| 2008 | Dan Hoevel, Kalamazoo |
| 2009 | Mark McLaughlin, Albion |
| 2010 | Jordan Kelly, Adrian |
| 2011 | Andy Thomson, Hope |
| 2012 | Brad Merritt, Kalamazoo |
| 2013 | Nick Julian, Olivet |
| 2014 | Brandon Snell, Trine |
| 2015 | Ben Hart, Olivet |
| 2016 | Connor Maddalena, Albion |
| 2017 | John VanNoord, Calvin |
