1970's
| 1978 | Albion 72, Otterbein, Ohio 67 (Regional) |
| Albion 91, Bethany, W.Va. 74 (Regional) | |
| Albion 78, Knoxville, Tenn. 77 (Quarters) | |
| North Park, Ill. 75, Albion 69 (Semis) | |
| Albion 87, SUNY-Stony Brook 78 (3rd Place) | |
| 1979 | Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 70, Albion 66 (Regional) |
| Albion 91, Allegheny, Pa. 78 (Regional) |
1980's
| 1980 | Ohio Northern 92, Calvin 90 (Regional) |
| Calvin 88, Wabash, Ind. 76 (Regional) | |
| 1981 | Wittenberg, Ohio 72, Calvin 50 (Regional) |
| Wabash, Ind. 93, Calvin 71 (Regional) | |
| 1982 | Hope 77, Wittenberg, Ohio 60 (Regional) |
| Wabash, Ind. 82, Hope 70 (Regional) | |
| 1983 | Hope 81, John Carroll, Ohio 72 (Regional) |
| Wittenberg, Ohio 63, Hope 55 (Regional) | |
| 1984 | Heidelberg, Ohio 73, Hope 69 (Regional) |
| Capital, Ohio 83, Hope 77 (ot) (Regional) | |
| 1985 | Hope 78, Otterbein, Ohio 71 (Regional) |
| Wittenberg, Ohio 68, Hope 63 (Regional) | |
| 1986 | Otterbein, Ohio 100, Calvin 84 (Regional) |
| Wittenberg, Ohio 84, Calvin 77 (Regional) | |
| 1987 | Otterbein, Ohio 95, Hope 80 (Regional) |
| Wittenberg, Ohio 70, Calvin 69 (Regional) | |
| Calvin 92, Hope 90 (ot) (Regional) | |
| 1988 | Hope 80, Muskingum, Ohio 75 (Regional) |
| Ohio Wesleyan 110, Hope 107 (2ot) (Regional) | |
| 1989 | Allegheny, Pa. 71, Hope 69 (First Round) |
| Calvin 69, Capital, Ohio 64 (First Round) | |
| Calvin 89, Allegheny, Pa. 87 (ot) (Regional) | |
| Otterbein, Ohio 93, Calvin 90 (Regional) |
1990's
| 1990 | Calvin 95, Hope 68 (Second Round) |
| Calvin 80, Emory, Ga. 73 (Sectional) | |
| Calvin 63, Wittenberg, Ohio 59 (Sectional) | |
| DePauw, Ind. 82, Calvin 79 (Semifinals) | |
| Washington, Md. 87, Calvin 86 (4th Place) | |
| 1991 | Calvin 85, Wooster, Ohio 68 (First Round) |
| Calvin 89, Hope 84 (ot) (Second Round) | |
| Calvin 76, Wartburg, Iowa 71 (Sectional) | |
| Otterbein, Ohio 75, Calvin 73 (Sectional) | |
| 1992 | Hope 76, Wittenberg, Ohio 60 (First Round) |
| Calvin 91, Hope 88 (Second Round) | |
| Calvin 69, Gustavus-Adolphus, Minn. 68 (Sectional) | |
| Calvin 88, Otterbein, Ohio 67 (Sectional) | |
| Calvin 81, Jersey City, N.J. 40 (Semifinals) | |
| Calvin 62, Rochester, N.Y. 49 (Championship game) | |
| 1993 | Calvin 90, Otterbein, Ohio 68 (Second Round) |
| Calvin 101, Emory & Henry, Va. 67 (Sectional) | |
| Ohio Northern 67, Calvin 56 (Sectional) | |
| 1994 | Wittenberg, Ohio 86, Calvin 81 (Second Round) |
| 1995 | Wittenberg, Ohio 62, Calvin 57 (First Round) |
| Baldwin-Wallace, Ohio 72, Hope 69 (First Round) | |
| 1996 | Hope 65, Kalamazoo 62 (First Round) |
| Hope 80, John Carroll, Ohio 61 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 88, Wis.-Whitewater 66 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 69, Wittenberg, Ohio 60 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 76, Franklin & Marshall, Pa. 57 (Semifinals) | |
| Rowan, N.J. 100, Hope 93 (Championship game) | |
| 1997 | Hope 69, Denison, Ohio 66 (First Round) |
| Hope 67, Wooster, Ohio 56 (Second Round) | |
| Nebraska Wesleyan 92, Hope 75 (Sectional) | |
| 1998 | John Carroll 70, Albion 52 (First Round) |
| Hope 80, Allegheny, Pa. 66 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 81, Christopher Newport, Va. 64 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 84, John Carroll, Ohio 66 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 81, Wilkes, Pa. 61 (Semifinals) | |
| Wis.-Platteville 69, Hope 56 (Championship game) | |
| 1999 | Otterbein, Ohio 104, Defiance 90 (First Round) |
2000's
| 2000 | Calvin 92, Franklin, Ind. 90 (ot) (Second Round) |
| Calvin 82, Wooster, Ohio 53 (Sectional) | |
| Calvin 115, McMurry, Tex. 79 (Sectional) | |
| Calvin 79, Franklin & Marshall, Pa. 77 (Semifinals) | |
| Calvin 79, Wis.-Eau Claire 74 (Championship game) | |
| 2001 | Calvin 89, Defiance, Ohio 78 (First Round) |
| Ohio Northern 79, Calvin 68 (Second Round) | |
| 2002 | Hope 54, St. Norbert, Wis. 53 (First Round) |
| Carthage, Wis. 63, Hope 57 (Second Round) | |
| 2003 | Wis.-Oshkosh 84, Hope 77 (Second Round) |
| 2004 | John Carroll, Ohio 88, Calvin 77 (Second Round) |
| 2005 | Calvin 75, Wheaton, Ill. 74 (First Round) |
| Calvin 71, Aurora, Ill. 59 (Second Round) | |
| Albion 59, Wooster, Ohio 58 (Second Round) | |
| Albion 80, John Carroll, Ohio 79 (Sectional) | |
| Calvin 75, Mississippi Coll. 60 (Sectional) | |
| Calvin 60, Albion 52 (Sectional) | |
| Rochester, N.Y. 65, Calvin 62 (Semifinals) | |
| Calvin 98, York, Pa. 84 (3rd Place) | |
| 2006 | Calvin 79, Wis.-LaCrosse 71 (First Round) |
| Hope 93, Wisconsin Lutheran 51 (First Round) | |
| Hope 70, Calvin 67 (Second Round) | |
| Wittenberg, Ohio 56, Hope 49 (Sectional) | |
| 2007 | Hope 76, Univ. of Chicago 54 (First Round) |
| Calvin 69, Aurora, Ill. 68 (First Round) | |
| Hope 80, Calvin 64 (Second Round) | |
| Hope 89, Carroll, Wis. 77 (Sectional) | |
| Washington, Mo. 58, Hope 55 (Sectional) | |
| 2008 | Hope 92, Capital, Ohio 72 (Second Round) |
| Hope 71, Ohio Wesleyan 63 (Sectional) | |
| Hope 83, Wheaton, Ill. 70 (Sectional) | |
| Washington, Mo. 89, Hope 74 (Semifinals) | |
| Hope 100, Ursinus, Pa. 86 (3rd place) | |
| 2009 | Wis.-Platteville 83, Hope 59 (First Round) |
2010's
| 2010 | St. Norbert, Wis. 72, Hope 65 (First Round) |
| 2011 | Hope 73, Hanover, Ind. 70 (First Round) |
| Augustana, Ill. 88, Hope 80 (ot) (Second Round) | |
| 2012 | Hope 79, Westminster, Mo. 65 (First Round) |
| Illinois Wesleyan 108, Hope 101 (2ot) (Second Round) | |
| 2013 | Calvin 72, Rose-Hulman, Ind. 52 (First Round) |
| Calvin 67, Wis.-Stevens Point 58 (Second Round) | |
| St. Thomas, Minn. 63, Calvin 62 (Third Round) | |
| 2014 | Calvin 66, Wittenberg, Ohio 51 (First Round) |
| Penn State-Behrend 70, Hope 66 (ot) (First Round) | |
| Calvin 83, Washington, Mo. 75 (Second Round) | |
| Illinois Wesleyan 78, Calvin 64 (Sectional) | |
| 2015 | Calvin 78, Oswego State, N.Y. 69 (First Round) |
| Mount Union, Ohio 81, Calvin 69 (Second Round) | |
| 2016 | Hope 98, Mt. St. Joseph 87 (First Round) |
| Alma 74, Denison 60 (First Round) | |
| Augustana (Ill.) 96, Hope 80 (Second Round) | |
| Alma 90, John Carroll 83 (Second Round) | |
| Alma 70, St. Norbert 64 (Sectional Semifinals) | |
| Benedictine (Ill.) 93, Alma 73 (Sectional Finals) | |
| 2017 | Hope 87, UW-Oshkosh 85 (First Round) |
| Marietta, Ohio 83, Calvin 66 (First Round) | |
| Hope 94, Washington, Mo. 80 (Second Round) | |
| Hanover, Ind. 79, Hope 77 (Sectional Semifinals) | |
| 2018 | Hope 93, Augsburg, Minn. 91 (First Round) |
| Augustana, Ill. 95, Hope 83 (Second Round) |
