| Date | Score | Game-Winning Play |
| 10-24-98 | Hope 43, Alma 37 | Tim Alles, 13-yard pass from Justin Wormmeester |
| 11-1-03 | Alma 24, Kalamazoo 23 | James Edington, 2-yard run; Jeff LaPorte PAT |
| 10-1-05 | Adrian 30, Albion 27 | James Spencer, 38-yard field goal |
| 10-15-05 | Adrian 37, Olivet 31, 2ot | DJ Howard, 13-yard pass from Randy Hutchison |
| 10-7-06 | Hope 49, Alma 43 | David Booko, 11-yard run |
| 10-7-06 | Kalamazoo 33, Tri-State 30, 2ot | Jon Rea, 20-yard field goal |
| 10-13-07 | Tri-State 23, Adrian 20 | Justin Hoover, 34-yard field goal |
| 11-05-11 | Hope 24, Adrian 21 | Evan Finch, 20-yard field goal |
| 11-03-12 | Adrian 20, Albion 19 | Justin Hemm, 8-yard pass from Taylor Copacia, Dustin Salliotte PAT |
| 10-05-13 | Olivet 20, Alma 13 | Javier Lara 17-yard run; Anthony Edwards PAT |
| 11-09-13 | Trine 47, Olivet 41 | Frank Vuocolo, 4-yard run |
| 10-04-14 | Albion 37, Hope 36 | Mike Czarnecki, 5-yard run; Cody Lehman PAT |
| 10-04-14 | Trine 26, Alma 23, 2ot | Joey Lopshire, 25-yard field goal |
| 10-11-14 | Hope 42, Olivet 35 | Taylor Brynaert, 16-yard pass from Robert Kish, Aaron Mick PAT |
updated through 2017 season
