1958 Ellis Cutler, Kalamazoo vs. Hillsdale (Kalamazoo 2, Hillsdale, 0)
1958 Carl Jacobson, Alma vs. Hope (Alma 7, Hope 0)
1959 Jim Northrup, Alma vs. Calvin (Alma 7, Calvin 0

1960 Terry Ebright, Alma vs. Calvin (Alma 14, Calvin 0)
1965 Don Kroodsma, Hope vs. Alma (Hope 17, Alma 0)
1966 Tim Pete, Alma vs. Olivet (Alma 1, Olivet 0)

1970 Duncan Beagle, Albion vs. Hope (Albion 2, Hope 0)
1971 Dave Rowley, Kalamazoo vs. Adrian (Kalamazoo 5, Adrian 0)
1972 Larry Hourtienne, Alma vs. Olivet, losing pitcher (Olivet 1, Alma 0)
1975 Dewey McCoy, Alma vs. Calvin (Alma 1, Calvin 0)
1978 Mike Gnatkowski, Alma vs. Olivet (Alma 5, Olivet 1)

1983 Bob Varner, Albion vs. Hope (Albion 1, Hope 0)
1984 John Klunder, Hope vs. Olivet (Hope 10, Olivet 0)
1985 Greg Heeres, Hope vs. Kalamazoo (Hope 3, Kalamazoo 0)

1990 Mark Smith, Albion vs. Adrian (Albion 11, Adrian 0, perfect game)
1990 Andy Bradford, Kalamazoo vs. Albion (Kalamazoo 1, Albion 0)
1991 Mark Smith, Albion vs. Alma (Albion 6, Alma 1)
1993 Steve Schewe, Hope vs. Olivet (Hope 7, Olivet 1)
1994 Steve Guibord, Albion vs. Kalamazoo (Albion 30, Kalamazoo 0)
1995 Darin Corcoran, Hope vs. Kalamazoo (Hope 12, Kalamazoo 0)
1996 Eric Lewis, Olivet vs. Calvin (Olivet 1, Calvin 0)

2001 Chris Krebs, Alma vs. Kalamazoo (Alma 10, Kalamazoo 0)
2004 David Seales, Albion vs. Calvin (Albion 10, Calvin 0)
2009 Sean Alexander, Olivet vs. Kalamazoo (Olivet 2, Kalamazoo 1)
2009 Derek Fairchild, Hope vs. Albion (Hope 8, Albion 0)

2012 Joe Lambers and Nate Schepers, Calvin vs. Albion (Calvin 6, Albion 2) 
2013 Phil Stakely, Trine vs. Albion (Trine 10, Albion 0) 
2016 Tommy Parsons, Adrian, vs. Olivet, 3/25/16 (Adrian 8, Olivet 0)
2016 Mitch Sedlowsky, Albion vs. Olivet, 4/12/16 (Albion 2, Olivet 0)
2016 Ryan Orr, Kalamazoo vs. Olivet, 4/23/16 (Kalamazoo 2, Olivet 0)
2016 Alex Valasek, Alma vs. Olivet, 5/6/16 (Alma 10, Olivet 0)
2018 Ryan Orr, Kalamazoo vs. Albion, 4/18/18 (Kalamazoo 7, Albion 0)