(Career records are since 18-game season started in 1992)
BATTING AVERAGE (Min. 100 at bats)
| .456 | Alex Cowart, Adrian (327-149), 2007-10 |
| .408 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, (399-163), 2014-17 |
| .406 | Brian Myers, Albion (165-67), 1993-96 |
| .403 | Nate Sarkissian, Adrian (300-121), 2008-11 |
| .397 | Mark Kuiper, Hope (204-81), 1992-95 |
TIMES AT BAT
| 399 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, 2014-17 |
| 378 | Grant Van Putten, Calvin, 2012-15 |
| 368 | Jon Ponte, Hope, 2009-12 |
| 361 | Matt Sattler, Hope, 2005-08 |
| 343 | Todd Meyers, Adrian, 2006-09 |
MOST HITS
| 163 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, 2014-17 |
| 149 | Alex Cowart, Adrian, 2007-10 |
| 147 | Grant Van Putten, Calvin, 2012-15 |
| 131 | Matt Sattler, Hope, 2005-08 |
| 130 | Brian Bilius, Adrian, 2008-11 |
MOST DOUBLES
| 39 | Alex Cowart, Adrian, 2007-10 |
| 37 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, 2014-17 |
| 30 | Dan Slagle, Adrian, 1997-00 |
| 30 | Matt Sattler, Hope, 2005-08 |
| 30 | Aaron Wiers, Calvin, 1998-01 |
MOST TRIPLES
| 11 | Mitch Stefanski, Adrian, 2012-14 |
| 9 | Alex Cowart, Adrian, 2007-10 |
| 9 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, 2014-17 |
| 8 | Kyle Strawn, Adrian, 2009-12 |
| 7 | Tom Osborn, Hope, 1992-95 |
| 7 | Matt Sattler, Hope, 2005-08 |
| 7 | Matt Schepel, Calvin, 2007-09, 2014 |
MOST HOME RUNS
| 19 | Colton Wolfe, Calvin, 2014-17 |
| 14 | Alex Cowart, Adrian, 2007-10 |
| 14 | Brad Lauchner, Trine, 2007-10 |
| 14 | Derek Tracy, Albion, 2006-07 |
| 14 | Dan Slagle, Adrian, 1997-00 |
| 14 | B.J. Maas, Hope, 2001-03 |
| 14 | Mike VanBeek, Hope, 2000-03 |
| 14 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, 2014-17 |
MOST RBIs
| 111 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, 2014-17 |
| 106 | Alex Cowart, Adrian, 2007-10 |
| 96 | Nate Sarkissian, Adrian, 2008-11 |
| 87 | Todd Meyers, Adrian, 2006-09 |
| 83 | Bobby Rickstad, Adrian, 2005-08 |
| 83 | Matt Schepel, Calvin, 2007-09, 2014 |
TOTAL BASES
| 260 | Ryan Dorow, Adrian, 2014-17 |
| 248 | Alex Cowart, Adrian, 2007-10 |
| 199 | Matt Schepel, Calvin, 2007-09, 2014 |
| 198 | Colton Wolfe, Calvin, 2014-17 |
| 193 | Matt Sattler, Hope, 2005-08 |
| 183 | Nate Sarkissian, Adrian, 2008-11 |
| 183 | Grant Van Putten, Calvin, 2012-15 |
STOLEN BASES
| 62 | Grant Van Putten, Calvin, 2012-15 |
| 58 | Ray Ribitch, Alma, 2003-06 |
| 39 | David Kamerman, Kalamazoo, 2009-12 |
| 39 | Alex Cowart, Adrian, 2007-10 |
| 39 | Matt Sattler, Hope, 2005-08 |
| 34 | Brendan Diamond, Albion, 2012-14 |
INNINGS PITCHED
| 196 | John Fileccia, Albion, 2005-08 |
| 189 | Craig Reynolds, Adrian, 2003-06 |
| 184 | Mike Schypinski, Albion, 2010-13 |
| 180 | Jeff Nokovich, Adrian, 2003-06 |
| 173 | Chris Gumper, Olivet, 1993-96 |
| 170 | Ryan Gunderson, Albion, 2006-09 |
MOST DECISIONS
| 27 | Bobby Wrozek, Adrian, 2001-04 (15-11-1) |
| 27 | Mike Schypinski, Albion, 2010-13 (17-10) |
| 26 | Peter Steiner, Calvin, 2008-11 (18-8) |
| 26 | Craig Reynolds, Adrian, 2003-06 (17-9) |
| 25 | Ryan Domschot, Adrian, 2008-11 (20-5) |
| 25 | Ryan Gunderson, Albion, 2006-09 (15-10) |
MOST VICTORIES
| 20 | Ryan Domschot, Adrian, 2008-11 (20-5) |
| 20 | Eric Schmidt, Adrian, 2012-15 (20-2) |
| 18 | Jim Deters, Calvin, 2002-05 (18-3) |
| 18 | Keith Spoelstra, Calvin, 2008-11 (18-6) |
| 18 | Peter Steiner, Calvin, 2008-11 (18-8) |
| 18 | Adam Clements, Hope, 2009-12 (18-5) |
EARNED RUN AVERAGE (min 125 IP)
Calculated on NCAA 9 IP rule
| 1.60 | Jeff Nokovich, Adrian, 2003-06 (180 IP, 32 ER) |
| 1.76 | Jim Deters, Calvin, 2002-05 (169 IP, 33 ER) |
| 2.23 | Rylie Robinson, Adrian, 2011-14 (157-2/3 IP, 39 ER) |
| 2.55 | Mike Ott, Calvin, 1999-02 (169 IP, 48 ER) |
| 2.57 | Ryan Domschot, Adrian, 2008-11 (160-2/3 IP, 46ER) |
| 2.59 | Adam Clements, Hope, 2009-12 (163-1/3 IP, 47 ER) |
MOST STRIKEOUTS
| 232 | Jeff Nokovich, Adrian, 2003-06 (180 IP) |
| 210 | Jim Deters, Calvin, 2002-05 (215 IP) |
| 190 | Ryan Domschot, Adrian, 2008-11 (160-2/3 IP) |
| 172 | Adam Clements, Hope, 2009-12 (163-1/3 IP) |
| 150 | Chris Gumper, Olivet, 1993-96 (173 IP) |
| 147 | Mike Schypinski, Albion, 2010-13 (184 IP) |
* - active player
