1970's
| 1973 | Ronald Postuma, Hope | Football |
| 1979 | Craig Groendyk, Hope | Football |
| John Nibert, Albion | Basketball |
1980's
| 1980 | Greg Bekius, Hope | Football |
| Jamie VanArsdalen, Adrian | Basketball (2nd) | |
| 1982 | Kurt Brinks, Hope | Football |
| Brice Drogosch, Albion | Football | |
| David Hostetter, Alma | Baseball (2nd) | |
| John Schelske, Kalamazoo | Basketball (4th) | |
| 1983 | Sharon Boeve, Calvin | Softball (HM) |
| Richard Fabian, Albion | Baseball (3rd) | |
| Karen Hale, Albion | Softball (1st) | |
| 1984 | Steve Dembowski, Adrian | Football |
| Keith Devries, Hope | Wrestling (2nd) | |
| Scott Jecmen, Hope | Football | |
| James Kramer, Alma | Basketball (HM) | |
| Suzanne Leiby, Albion | Swimming (1st) | |
| Wendy Lombardi, Albion | Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Catherine Work, Hope | Tennis (2nd) | |
| 1985 | Irenna Garapetain, Alma | Field Hockey (3rd) |
| Anne Hendrickson, Hope | Softball (1st) | |
| Catherine Work, Hope | Tennis (1st) | |
| 1986 | Kim Baxter, Hope | Tennis (HM) |
| Tom Bylsma, Hope | Baseball (1st) | |
| Timothy Chase, Hope | Football (1st) | |
| Julie Dykstra, Calvin | Volleyball (3rd) | |
| Michael Grant, Albion | Football (1st) | |
| Greg Luczak, Alma | Baseball (2nd) | |
| Greg Luczak, Alma | Football (1st) | |
| Christopher Mack, Kalamazoo | Football (2nd) | |
| Daniel Stid, Hope | Football (2nd) | |
| 1987 | Kim Baxter, Hope | Tennis (3rd) |
| Anne Grieser, Adrian | Softball (1st) | |
| DeeAnn Knoll, Hope | Softball (3rd) | |
| Kim Niemeyer, Alma | Softball (3rd) | |
| 1988 | Tauna Jecmen, Hope | Cross Country/Track (3rd) |
| DeeAnn Knoll, Hope | Softball (1st) | |
| Cynthia Weisenauer, Albion | Softball (3rd) | |
| 1989 | Laurie Anne Hiemstra, Calvin | Softball (1st) |
| Tauna Jecmen, Hope | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Mike Nixon, Alma | Baseball (2nd |
1990's
| 1990 | Scott Bissell, Albion | Football (1st) |
| David Doyle, Kalamazoo | Football (2nd) | |
| Jodie McLean, Adrian | Softball (1st) | |
| Mike Nixon, Alma | Baseball (2nd) | |
| Kelly Spalding, Alma | Basketball (1st) | |
| 1991 | Nathan Eddy, Kalamazoo | Tennis (2nd) |
| Sean Mullendore, Kalamazoo | Football (2nd) | |
| Lisa Scheid, Adrian | Softball (3rd) | |
| 1992 | Jeffrey Bannink, Hope | Swimming (3rd) |
| Eric Baxmann, Albion | Football (2nd) | |
| Nathan Eddy, Kalamazoo | Tennis (1st) | |
| Steve Honderd, Calvin | Basketball (1st) | |
| Lewis Miller, Kalamazoo | Tennis (1st) | |
| Sean Mullendore, Kalamazoo | Football (1st) | |
| Johanna Pscodna, Hope | Softball (2nd) | |
| Darren Zwick, Olivet | Basketball (2nd) | |
| 1993 | Jeffrey Bannink, Hope | Swimming (1st) |
| Jamie Crooks, Hope | Basketball (1st) | |
| Steve Goda, Adrian | Baseball (3rd) | |
| Steve Honderd, Calvin | Basketball (2nd) | |
| Chris Knoester, Calvin | Basketball (3rd) | |
| Lewis Miller, Kalamazoo | Tennis (1st) | |
| Liz Ruhl, Adrian | Softball (2nd) | |
| Eric Baxmann, Albion | Football (1st) | |
| Jeffrey Shooks, Albion | Football (1st) | |
| Jeffrey Toner, Adrian | Football (2nd) | |
| 1994 | Christopher Behling, Albion | Swimming (1st) |
| Adam Beach, Adrian | Baseball (1st) | |
| Mark Kuiper, Hope | Baseball (2nd) | |
| Chris Knoester, Calvin | Basketball (1st) * | |
| Jay Overmyer, Adrian | Football (1st) | |
| Jeffrey Shooks, Albion | Football (1st) | |
| Ray VanArragon, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| 1995 | Jennifer Babcock, Adrian | Softball (3rd) |
| Matt Bruder, Adrian | Baseball (3rd) | |
| Mark Kuiper, Hope | Baseball (1st) | |
| David Lefere, Albion | Football (1st) | |
| Ray VanArragon, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Amy Kuipers, Calvin | Cross Country (1st) | |
| Christie Cleland, Albion | Soccer (3rd) | |
| 1996 | Jeremy Cole, Kalamazoo | Basketball (2nd) |
| Sara Musser, Kalamazoo | Basketball (2nd) | |
| Laurie Byington, Hope | Softball (2nd) | |
| Christie Cleland, Albion | Softball (2nd) | |
| Holly Breuker, Calvin | Track (1st) | |
| Amy Kuipers, Calvin | Track (1st) | |
| Mike Jehle, Albion | Baseball (2nd) | |
| David Lefere, Albion | Football (1st) | |
| Kyle Klein, Albion | Football (2nd) | |
| Todd Alcock, Adrian | Football (2nd) | |
| Lance Sanders, Kalamazoo | Football (2nd) | |
| Brent Baska, Adrian | Football (2nd) | |
| Cherokee Hoagland, Adrian | Basketball (1st) | |
| 1997 | Sam Glass, Calvin | Soccer (2nd) |
| Will Watts, Calvin | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Kip Adrian, Kalamazoo | Soccer (1st) | |
| Betsy Haverkamp, Calvin | Cross Country (1st) | |
| Marie Matchett, Hope | Cross Country (3rd) | |
| Shauna Koolhaas, Calvin | Softball (1st) | |
| Melanie Bolt, Calvin | Softball (1st) | |
| Melanie Hariff, Calvin | Softball (3rd) | |
| David Lefere, Albion | Baseball (1st) | |
| Eve Halderson, Kalamazoo | Tennis (1st) | |
| Betsy Haverkamp, Calvin | Track (1st) | |
| Audrey Coates, Hope | Tennis (2nd) | |
| Andrea Clark, Calvin | Track (3rd) | |
| Pat Noud, Kalamazoo | Tennis (3rd) | |
| Brandon Graham, Hope | Football (2nd) | |
| 1998 | Sam Glass, Calvin | Soccer (2nd) |
| Marisa Proctor, Alma | Diving (2nd) | |
| Ellen Schultz, Hope | Cross Country (2nd) | |
| Cara Jansen, Calvin | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Shauna Koolhaas, Calvin | Softball (2nd) | |
| Melanie Harriff, Calvin | Softball (3rd) | |
| Mike Meeuwsen, Hope | Baseball (1st) | |
| Andrea Clark, Calvin | Track (2nd) | |
| Rick Brands, Alma | Football (1st) | |
| Dave DeHommel, Hope | Football (2nd) | |
| Nick Gates, Albion | Football (2nd) | |
| 1999 | Aaron Winkle, Calvin | Basketball (2nd) |
| Rebecca Timmer, Hope | Cross Country (1st) | |
| Cara Jansen, Calvin | Soccer (2nd) | |
| Andrea Clark, Calvin | Cross Country (3rd) | |
| Scott Westhouse, Calvin | Cross Country (3rd) | |
| Steve Michmerhuizen, Calvin | Track (1st) | |
| Phil Sikkenga, Calvin | Track (3rd) | |
| Sarah Gritter, Calvin | Track (2nd) | |
| Dustin Armstrong, Alma | Football (1st) | |
| Nick Gates, Albion | Football (2nd) | |
| Jason Mensing, Adrian | Football (2nd |
2000's
| 2000 | Aaron Winkle, Calvin | Basketball (2nd) |
| Markus Boos, Kalamazoo | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Sarah Gritter, Calvin | Cross Country (1st) | |
| Joel Klooster, Calvin | Cross Country (3rd) | |
| Elizabeth VandenBerg, Hope | Swimming (1st) | |
| Kim Grotenhuis, Hope | Softball (1st) | |
| Kathryn Nordin, Alma | Softball (1st) | |
| Phil Sikkenga, Calvin | Track (3rd) | |
| Mark DeWeerd, Calvin | Track (3rd) | |
| Sarah Gritter, Calvin | Track (1st) | |
| Kim Grotenhuis, Hope | Volleyball (1st) | |
| 2001 | Paul Peterson, Calvin | Cross Country (1st) |
| Joel Klooster, Calvin | Cross Country (1st) | |
| Sarah Gritter, Calvin | Cross Country (1st) | |
| Erinn Boot, Calvin | Cross Country (3rd) | |
| Evan Whitbeck, Kalamazoo | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Kim Grotenhuis, Hope | Softball (1st) | |
| Phil Sikkenga, Calvin | Track (2nd) | |
| Mark DeWeerd, Calvin | Track (2nd) | |
| Paul Petersen, Calvin | Track (3rd) | |
| Brant Haverdink, Kalamazoo | Football (1st) | |
| John Bennink, Albion | Football (2nd) | |
| Liz Hermiller, Albion | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Lydia Raburn, Kalamazoo | Soccer (2nd) | |
| David Dwaihy, Kalamazoo | Soccer (1st) | |
| Jon Hughes, Kalamazoo | Soccer (1st) | |
| 2002 | Emily Arend, Albion | Tennis (1st) |
| Evan Whitbeck, Kalamazoo | Swimming (1st) | |
| Kyle Harding, Kalamazoo | Tennis (2nd) | |
| Joel Klooster, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st)** | |
| Dan Hoekstra, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (2nd) | |
| David Ritsema, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (2nd) | |
| Jeremy Butler-Pinkham, Adrian | Cross Country (3rd) | |
| Erinn Boot, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Laurie Vance, Albion | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Kim Hartman, Kalamazoo | Soccer (1st) | |
| Jon Hughes, Kalamazoo | Soccer (2nd) | |
| 2003 | Megan Russell, Albion | Softball (3rd) |
| Scott Miller, Olivet | Golf (3rd) | |
| Joel Klooster, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Joel Veldhouse, Calvin | Soccer (1st) | |
| Andrew Kemple, Kalamazoo | Soccer (3rd) | |
| 2004 | Megan Russell, Albion | Softball (3rd) |
| Tim Avery, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Hendrik Kok, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Matt Edwards, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (3rd) | |
| Laura Hamilton, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (2nd) | |
| Jessie Lair, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (3rd) | |
| Joel Veldhouse, Calvin | Soccer (1st) | |
| Travis Sleight, Olivet | Football (2nd) | |
| 2005 | Hendrik Kok, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (2nd) |
| Nate Meckes, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (2nd) | |
| Jeff Engbers, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (3rd) | |
| Meaghan Clark, Kalamazoo | Tennis (2nd) | |
| Laura Hamilton, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Missy Smith, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (3rd) | |
| Travis Sleight, Olivet | Football (1st) | |
| 2006 | Lisa Winkle, Calvin | Basketball (2nd) |
| Dustin Meisner, Olivet | Swimming (3rd) | |
| Becky Weima, Calvin | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Harrison Jorritsma, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Nate Meckes, Calvin | Track (3rd) | |
| Missy Smith, Calvin | Track (1st) | |
| Christine Hendricks, Calvin | Track (1st) | |
| Stephanie Green, Olivet | Track & Field(3rd) | |
| 2007 | Lisa Winkle, Calvin | Basketball (1st) |
| Stephanie Smith, Olivet | Basketball (2nd) | |
| Andrew Lansang, Olivet | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Marc Miller, Olivet | Football (2nd) | |
| Neil Forster, Albion | Tennis (1st) | |
| Laura Winkler, Kalamazoo | Volleyball (3rd) | |
| Becky Weima, Calvin | Swimming (1st) | |
| Harrison Jorritsma, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Dustin Meisner, Olivet | Swimming (1st) | |
| Ryan TerLouw, Hope | Track & Field (1st) | |
| Lisa Winkle, Calvin | Track & Field (1st) | |
| Sarah Wittingen, Calvin | Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Rafael Siebenschein, Calvin | Tennis (3rd) | |
| 2008 | Kylee Brouwer, Hope | Softball (1st) |
| Ricky Tilton, Calvin | Tennis (3rd) | |
| Dustin Meisner, Olivet | Swimming (1st) | |
| Cara VanWoerkom, Calvin | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Sarah Wittingen, Calvin | Track & Field (1st) | |
| 2009 | Anna Braner, Olivet | Softball (1st) |
| Jessica Koster, Calvin | Cross Country/Track (1st) | |
| Nora Kuiper, Hope | Track & Field (1st)*** | |
| Cara VanWoerkom, Calvin | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Lindsay Pipkin, Olivet |
Golf (2nd) |
|
| Erik Van Kampen, Calvin |
Cross Country/Track (2nd) |
|
| Kyle Vanderhyde, Olivet |
Wrestling (1st) |
|
| Sarah Wittingen, Calvin |
Track & Field (1st) |
2010's
| 2010 | Brandon Luczak, Kalamazoo | Football (1st) |
| Nate Kopydlowski, Kalamazoo | Football (1st) | |
| Jeremy Howard, Trine | Football (2nd) | |
| Rebecca Kamp, Calvin | Volleyball (1st) | |
| Greg Snapper, Calvin | Soccer (2nd) | |
| Allison Boender, Calvin | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Kellen Beckwith, Olivet | Swimming (1st) | |
| Melissa Oosterhouse, Calvin | Tennis (1st) | |
| Ashley Peterson, Saint Mary's | Softball (2nd) | |
| Monica Bressler, Calvin | Swimming (3rd) | |
| John Donkersloot, Hope | Track & Field (1st) | |
| Jessica Koster, Calvin | Track & Field (1st) | |
| Jeffrey Minkus, Hope | Track & Field (3rd) | |
| 2011 | Tyler Terry, Trine | Football (2nd) |
| Elaine Schnabel, Calvin | Soccer (1st) | |
| Kellen Beckwith, Olivet**** | Swimming (1st) | |
| Craig Fleming, Kalamazoo | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Michael Harden, Olivet | Swimming (3rd) | |
| Monica Bressler, Calvin | Swimming (3rd) | |
| Melissa Oosterhouse, Calvin | Tennis (1st) | |
| Alex Dombos, Kalamazoo | Tennis (2nd) | |
| Tyler Millward, Albion | Baseball (3rd) | |
| John Donkersloot, Hope | Track & Field (1st) | |
| 2012 | Steve Mauk, Adrian | Football(1st) |
| Miles Colago, Calvin | Soccer (2nd) | |
| Rebecca Kamp, Calvin***** | Volleyball (1st) | |
| Lizzie Kamp, Calvin | Volleyball (2nd) | |
| Carissa Verkaik, Calvin | Basketball (3rd) | |
| Michael Harden, Olivet | Swimming (1st) | |
| Chelsea Wiese, Hope | Swimming (3rd) | |
| Kevin Lodewyk, Kalamazoo | Swimming (3rd) | |
| Laura Tjepkema, Hope | Softball (3rd) | |
| Alex Dombos, Kalamazoo | Tennis (1st) | |
| Kelsey Hassevoort, Kalamazoo | Tennis (1st) | |
| Dan Kerr, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Greg Whittle, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Nicole Michmerhuizen, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (3rd) | |
| 2013 | C.J. Carroll, Albion | Football (2nd) |
| Lizzie Kamp, Calvin***** | Volleyball (1st) | |
| Carissa Verkaik, Calvin# | Basketball (1st) | |
| Mark Ghafari, Kalamazoo | Basketball (3rd) | |
| Laura Tjepkema, Hope | Softball (1st) | |
| Bree Fuller, Trine | Softball (3rd) | |
| Cory Schmidt, Hope | Baseball (2nd) | |
| William Guedes, Kalamazoo | Swimming (1st) | |
| Dan Kerr, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Greg Whittle, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Nicole Michmerhuizen, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Job Christiansen, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| 2014 | Travis Vegter, Calvin | Soccer (1st) |
| Jenna Mayle, Olivet | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Maggie Kamp, Calvin | Volleyball (2nd) | |
| Chelsea Ciba, Olivet | Basketball (1st) | |
| Mark Ghafari, Kalamazoo | Basketball (1st) | |
| Megan Kelley, Hope | Basketball (2nd) | |
| Carly Searles, Trine | Softball (1st) | |
| Bree Fuller, Trine | Softball (2nd) | |
| Adrienne Plourde, Olivet | Golf (2nd) | |
| Jeff Holm, Olivet | Wrestling (3rd) | |
| Nicole Michmerhuizen, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Sheri McCormack, Hope | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Jalen Weaver, Olivet | Cross Country/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Jenna Mayle, Olivet | Cross Country/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Hilary Banning, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Erik Holstege, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (3rd) | |
| Trisha King, Trine | Cross Country/Track & Field (3rd) | |
| 2015 | Travis Vegter, Calvin | Soccer (2nd) |
| Lucy Mailing, Kalamazoo | Soccer (2nd) | |
| Kirby Crook, Hope | Football (1st) | |
| Aaron Wolf, Trine | Football (1st) | |
| Maggie Kamp, Calvin***** | Volleyball (1st) | |
| Jenna Grasmeyer, Hope | Volleyball (2nd) | |
| Elise Biesboer, Calvin | Volleyball (3rd) | |
| Jordan Brink, Calvin | Basketball (2nd) | |
| Julie Sobieski, Hope | Softball (1st) | |
| Morgan Brandt, Adrian | Softball (3rd) | |
| William Guedes, Kalamazoo | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Joe Silvestri, Albion | Lacrosse (2nd) | |
| Carli Capestany, Hope | Tennis (2nd) | |
| Sarah Sheridan, Hope | Swimming (3rd) | |
| Kaitlyn Arnold, Alma | Cross Country/Track & Field (3rd) | |
| 2016 | Jared Holmquist, Trine* | Basketball (1st) |
| Boone Marois, Hope | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Ryan Anderson, Olivet | Football (1st) | |
| Travis Lankerd, Olivet | Football (1st) | |
| Andrew DiFranco, Albion | Football (1st) | |
| Leah Lupu, Olivet | Swimming (3rd) | |
| Brett Stoughton, Calvin | Swimming (2nd) | |
| Michael Mertz, Adrian | Tennis (3rd) | |
| Jenna Lodewyk, Calvin | Volleyball (2nd) | |
| Isabelle Leon, Olivet | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Jordan Daley, Calvin | Basketball (1st) | |
| Lauren Strohbehn, Calvin | Cross County/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Andrew Prince, Albion | Soccer (3rd) | |
| Maura McAfee, Hope | Basketball (2nd) | |
| Ben Gardner, Hope | Basketball (3rd) | |
| Allyson Schultz, Olivet | Cross Country/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Kaitlyn Arnold, Alma | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| 2017 | Harrison Blackledge, Hope | Basketball (1st) |
| Brett Stoughton, Calvin | Swimming (1st) | |
| Sarah Bradley, Calvin | Diving (3rd) | |
| Kaitlyn Arnold, Alma | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Lauren Strohbehn, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (1st) | |
| Jordan Kramer, Calvin | Cross Country/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Connor Bauserman, Olivet | Cross Country/Track & Field (2nd) | |
| Jacob Witte, Calvin | Soccer (1st) | |
| David Vanderkloot, Kalamazoo | Football (2nd) | |
| Evan Wyse, Trine | Football (2nd) | |
| Jenna Lodwewyk, Calvin ***** | Volleyball (1st) | |
| Christina Dandar, Kalamazoo | Soccer (1st) | |
| Isabelle Leon, Olivet | Soccer (1st) |
* Named GTE Academic All-America of the year in men's basketball.
** Named CoSIDA Academic All-America of the year in men's cross country/track and field
*** Named CoSIDA Academic All-America of the year in women's cross country/track and field
**** Named CoSIDA Academic All-America of the year in men's at-large category
***** Named CoSIDA Academic All-America of the year in volleyball
# Named CoSIDA Academic All-America of the year in women's basketball
