(Volleyball became a league sport in 1978; all-MIAA teams have been named since 1982.)

AB- Albion; AD- Adrian; AM- Alma; C- Calvin; D- Defiance;
HO- Hope; K- Kalamazoo; O- Olivet; SM- Saint Mary's;
TR- Trine (Tri-State)

1980's

1982
Lynn Bolt, C
Mindy Cubitt, AM
Jill Forhan, AM
Dana Johnson, AM
Linda Percy, HO
Deb Verhill, C (MVP)

1983
Sue Agosti, AD
Lynn Bolt, C
Leah Calsbeek, C
Jill Forhan, AM
Dana Johnson, AM (MVP)
Linda Percy, HO (MVP)

1984
Sue Agosti, AD
Lynn Bolt, C
Leah Calsbeek, C (MVP)
Kathy DeHaan, C
Anne Hendrickson, HO
Dana Johnson, AM

1985
Sue Agosti, AD
Leah Calsbeck, C
Chris Carson, AM
Kathy DeHaan, C
Julie Dykstra, C (MVP)
Kim Lautenbach, C

1986
Leah Calsbeek, C (MVP)
Julie Dykstra, C (MVP)
Roxanne Helmus, C
Tammy Holloway, AD
DeeAnn Knoll, HO
Holly VandenBerg, HO

1987
Amber Blankespoor, C
Laurel Calsbeek, C
DeeAnn Knoll, HO (MVP)
Leslie Madill, AB
Robin Milligan, K
Holly VandenBerg, HO

1988
Amber Blankespoor, C (MVP)
Laurel Calsbeek, C
Mary Gerdes, K
Laura Holmes, AM
Judi Sebolka, AB
Holly VandenBerg, HO

1989
Amber Blankespoor, C (MVP)
Holly Brown, HO
Mary Gerdes, K
Laura Holmes, AM
Kris Speidel, C
Holly VandenBerg, HO

1990's

1990
Rocky Cibor, K
Laura Holmes, AM
Pam Van Tol, C
Janine Whittemore, HO
Karen Willms, K
Mei Zhang, K (MVP)

1991
Rocky Cibor, K
Taeko Nishimoto, AM
Pam VanTol, C
Christen Veltman, C
Karen Willms, K
Mei Zhang, K (MVP)

1992
Christina Garry, K
Taeko Nichimoto, AM
Mary Siwajek, K
Pam VanTol, C
Christen Veltman, C
Betsy Wilgenburg, C (MVP)

1993
Rachel Schepel, C
Stephanie Degg, AM
Christy Keen, C
Tina Klaczkiewicz, AM
Cara Marker, K
Susie Schulz, AB
Mary Siwajek, K (MVP)
Michelle Werkman, HO

1994
Stephanie Degg, AM
Kristine Den Hollander, C
Anita Grinbergs, K
Beth Hoezee, HO
Tina Klaczkiewicz, AM
Cara Marker, K
Mary Siwajek, K (MVP)
Michelle Werkman, HO

1995
Stephanie Degg, AM
Kristine Den Hollander, C
Anita Grinbergs, K (MVP)
Beth Hoezee, HO
Cara Marker, K
Narci Ritchie, O
Erika Van Stralen, C
Michelle Werkman, HO

1996
Emily Bakker, HO
Kristine Den Hollander, C (MVP)
Christie Eding, HO
Jill Harkema, C
Amy Pickelmann, AM
Stacey Saunders, K
Erica Van Stralen, C
Heather Velting, HO

1997
Ellen Bradbury, AM
Liz de Haan, HO
Kris Griffith, AD
Erin Hall
Stacey Saunders, K
Becky Schmidt, HO (MVP)
Erika VanStralen, C
Heather Velting, HO

1998
Jenny Barnes, AB
Agnes Bill, SM
Erin Hall, C
Charla Holmes, C
Stacey Saunders, K
Becky Schmidt, HO (MVP)
Heather Velting, HO
Rhonda Volkers, C

1999
Sara Arenholz, C
Agnes Bill, SM
Meghann Devlin, AM
Kim Grotenhuis, HO
Lisa Herron, K
Charla Holmes, C
Heather Velting, HO
Rhonda Volkers, C (MVP)

2000's

2000
Sara Ahrenholz, C
Amy Brower, HO
Meghann Devlin, AM
Kim Grotenhuis, HO
Laura Hahnfeld, HO
Michelle Hind, AB
Emily Trahan, K
Rhonda Volkers, C (MVP)

2001
Sara Ahrenholz, C
Amy Brower, HO (MVP)
Lauree Dermeyer, AD
Kristin Judson, AM
Melissa Pell, C
Sarah Seiler, AM
Emily Trahan, K
Kara VanAssen, HO

2002
Lindsey Baker, AM
Lauree Dermeyer, AD
Kristin Judson, AM
Martha Luidens, HO
Melissa Pell, C
Anny Price, K
Emily Trahan, K (MVP)
Laura Tucker, C

2003
Lindsey Baker, AM (MVP)
Trisha Balkema, C
Lauree Dermyer, AD
Kacie Ehinger, AD
Kara Kuipers, C
Kristen Playko, SM
Anny Price, K
McKenna Troyan, HO

2004
Lindsey Baker, AM (MVP)
Erin Fralick, AM
Kara Kuipers, C
Lauree Dermyer, AD
Anny Price, K
Kristin Judson, AM
Kristin DeGroot, C
Katie Zondervan, C

2005
Lindsey Eshelman, AD
Erin Fralick, AM (MVP)
Christine Hendricks, C
Amber Hoezee, HO
Stephanie Poll, HO
Julie VanderSlice, HO
Lorilyn Vogel, C
Katie Zondervan, C

2006
Anne Cusack, SM
Amber Hoezee, HO
Lindsey Eshelman, AD
Kristen Kalb, C (not All-MIAA but MVP)
Molly Krikke, C
Kelsee Krull,AM
Abby Sikora, AD
Deena VanAssen, HO
Katie Zondervan, C

2007
Kristen Kalb, C
Molly Krikke, C (MVP)
Sara Morningstar, AD
Tia Roberts, TR
Nora Slenk, HO
Morgan Watler, AB
Laura Winkler, K
Katie Zondervan, C

2008
Jenny Carlson, AD
Kim Gillhespy, AM
Andrea Helminiak, HO
Rebecca Kamp, C (MVP)
Sallie Richardson, TR
Kelsey Sears, C
Nora Slenk, HO
Kara VandeGuchte, HO

2009
Jacie Fiedler, HO
Hannah Hewitt, AM
Andrea Helminiak, HO (MVP)
Rebecca Kamp, C
Kelsey Sears, C
Lorna Slupczynski, SM
Kara VandeGuchte, HO
Morgan Watler, AB

2010's

2010
Stephanie Bradshaw, AM
Greer Bratschie, HO
Jacie Fiedler, HO
Betsy Irwin, TR
Lizzie Kamp, C
Rebecca Kamp, C (MVP)
Colleen Leonard, K
Megan Rietema, C

2011
Greer Bratschie, HO
Shelby Gray, AM
Jenna Grasmeyer, HO
Betsy Irwin, TR
Lizzie Kamp, C
Rebecca Kamp, C (MVP)
Colleen Leonard, K
Megan Rietema, C

2012
Greer Bratschie, HO
Jenna Grasmeyer, HO
Julia Hilbrands, C
Betsy Irwin, TR
Lizzie Kamp, C (MVP)
Megan Rietema, C
Kati Schneider, SM
Mari Schoolmaster, HO

2013
Courtney Earles, HO
Jenna Grasmeyer, HO
Lauren Hazekamp, HO
Maggie Kamp, C
Lea Klooster, AM
Megan Rietema, C (MVP)
Kati Schneider, SM
Kristen Zietse, C

2014
Laura Danhoff, C
Jenna Grasmeyer, HO
Hannah Guilford, AM
Lauren Hazekamp, HO
Maggie Kamp, C (MVP)
Jenna Lodewyk, C
Carly Searles, TR
Amy VanderStoep, HO

2015
Jordan Brisson, AD
Hannah Guilford, AM
Laura Danhoff, C
Maggie Kamp, C (MVP)
Jenna Lodewyk, C
Lauren Hazekamp, HO
Marissa Guile, OL
Katie Hecklinski, SM

2016
Laura Danhoff, C (MVP)
Meaghan Gibbons, SM
Sophia Hackett, HO
Margo Joubran, AD
Anna Kamp, C
Jenna Lodewyk, C
Ami Milligan, AB
Alexis Thompson, HO

2017
Paige Baker, HO
Rachel Bonek, SM
Marielle Corbett, SM
Sarah DeVries, C
Sophie Hackett, HO
Anna Kamp, C (MVP)
Jenna Lodewyk, C
Monica Shuk, AB

2018
Keilahna Castillo, C
Sarah DeVries, C
Anna Kamp, C (MVP)
Sara Majerle, AM
Haley Novak, AM
McKenna Otto, HO
Brittney Prince, OL
Katie Rietberg, HO
Taylor Rosenthal, AB
Monica Shuk, AB