All-Time MIAA Most Valuable Players

1980's

1983	Sharon Boeve, Calvin
1984	Sharon Boeve, Calvin
1985	Melody Janson, Albion
1986	Sal DeGraw, Alma
1987	Jessica Schrier, Calvin
1988	Ann Boshoven, Calvin
1989	Laurie Hiemstra, Calvin

1990's

1990	Kristi Klaasen, Calvin
1991	Lisa Walters, Hope
1992	Johanna Pscodna, Hope
1993	Karen Baird, Adrian
1994	Rachel Butler, Alma
1995	Julie Hoffman, Alma
1996	Shauna Koolhaas, Calvin
1997	Melanie Bolt & Shauna Koolhaas, Calvin
1998	Carolyn Whyte, Alma
1999	Jessica Davenport, Olivet

2000's

2000	Brandee Brower, Alma
2001	Carrie Scott, Hope
2002	Andrea Adams, Hope
2003	Erin Carson, Alma
2004	Leigh Ann LaFave, Alma
2005	Leigh Ann LaFave, Alma
2006	Kristin Amram, Saint Mary's
2007	Kay McDonald, Alma (pitcher) Rainbow Bednarski, Tri-State (position player)
2008	Elise English, Tri-State (pitcher) Kylee Brouwer, Hope (position player)
2009	Kelly Tomasek, Adrian (pitcher) Kelli Duimstra, Hope (position player)

2010's

2010	Tara Leddy, Alma (pitcher) Ashley Peterson, Saint Mary's (position player)
2011	Andrea Reinecke, Hope (pitcher) Kelly Koenigsknecht, Alma (position player)
2012	Andi Gasco, Trine (pitcher) Andi Gasco, Trine (position player)
2013	Andi Gasco, Trine (pitcher) Sarah Belote, Trine (position player)
2014	Bree Fuller, Trine (pitcher) Devan Olah, Alma (position player)
2015	Carly Searles, Trine (position player) Justine Robles, Trine (pitcher)
2016	Cassie Young, Saint Mary's (position player) Morgan Stratton, Alma (pitcher)
2017	Cassie Young, Saint Mary's (position player)
	Sydney Jones, Hope (pitcher)

2018	Hayley Reitsma, Hope (position player)
	Morgan Raymer, Saint Mary's (pitcher)

MIAA Most Valuable Offensive Player
(Started in 2003)

2003	Erin Carson, Alma
2004	Erin Sullivan, Saint Mary's
2005	Jeanne Cole, Calvin
2006	Jessica Regnerus, Hope
	discontinued

MIAA Most Valuable Defensive Player
(Started in 2003)

2003	Rachelle Heyboer, Calvin
2004	Katrina Tebbe, Saint Mary's
2005	Jeanne Cole, Calvin
2006	Becky Whitman, Hope
	discontinued

America's First Conference