(Softball became a league sport in 1979; all-MIAA selections have been made since 1983)
AB- Albion; AD- Adrian; AM- Alma; C- Calvin; D- Defiance;
HO- Hope; K- Kalamazoo; O- Olivet; SM- Saint Mary's;
TR/TS- Trine (Tri-State)
1983
Cathy Bachinski, AB
Sharon Boeve, C
Marge Caid, O
Terri Carvey, AM
Kelly Goodwin, O
Karen Hale, AB
Pam Harding, O
Pam Lancaster, C
Janna TerMolen, C
Laura Vroon, C
1984
Cathy Bachinski, AB
Sharon Boeve, C
Terri Carvey, AM
Bethy Clary, AB
Kathi Gilbert, AM
Ann (Pat) Harding, O
Cindy Short, AM
Sue Spagnuolo, AM
Janna TerMolen, C
Laura Vroon, C
1985
Sharon Boeve, C
Rhonda Buchanan, HO
Beth Clary, AB
Sal DeGraw, AM
Anne Hendrickson, HO
Melody Janson, AB
Sherri Maring, C
Cindy Short, AM
Sue Spagnuolo, AM
Annette Van Engen, HO
1986
Dianne Brown, HO
Beth Clary, AB
Sal DeGraw, AM
Linda DeWeerd, C
Meg Fowler, AM
Kathi Gilbert, AM
Barb Gras, HO
Ann Greiser, AD
Jessica Schrier, C
Ann Sheedy, AM
Marci Tawney, C
1987
Dianne Brown, HO
Rhonda Buchanan, HO
Sue Cato, O
Meg Fowler, AM
Anne Greiser, AD
Roxanne Helmus, C
Laurie Hiemstra, C
Jessica Schrier, C
Holly VandenBerg, HO
Lorri Vettes, AD
1988
Stephanie Bailey, AM
Kelly Baker, AD
Anne Boshoven, C
Dianne Brown, HO
Rhonda Buchanan, HO
Doretta Diekman, C
Barb Gras, HO
Laurie Hiemstra, C
Kim Johnson, AM
Chris Pscodna, C
1989
Stephanie Bailey, AM
Kelly Baker, AD
Anne Boshoven, C
Dianne Brown, HO
Laurie Hiemstra, C
Treeter Johnson, AM
Kristi Klaasen, C
Eileen Malkewitz, HO
Sarah Ondersma, C
Heidi Rottman, C
1990
Stephanie Bailey, AM
Amy Freimund, AD
Shannon Gaul, AD
Laurie Hiemstra, C
Treeter Johnson, AM
Kristi Klassen, C
Jodie McLean, AD
Rebecca Rifenberg, K
Heidi Rottman, C
Sherrie Scholten, HO
1991
Karen Baird, AD
Amy Freimund, AD
Treeter Johnson, AM
Laurie LaBeau, AM
Lisa McCarthy, AM
Julie Overway, C
Johanna Pscodna, HO
Rebecca Rifenberg, K
Lisa Scheid, AD
Audrey Seymour, AD
Deb Vashaw, HO
Lisa Walters, HO
1992
Karen Baird, AD
Shannon Gaul, AD
Kristie Gauntt, HO
Kelly Lewis, AB
Lisa McCarthy, AM
Cheryl Moore, AB
Julie Overway, C
Shannon Pingston, AM
Johanna Pscodna, HO
Rebecca Rifenberg, K
Lisa Walters, HO
1993
Karen Baird, AD
Rachel Butler, AM
Laurie Byington, HO
Julie Hoffman, AM
Gretchen Humes, AB
Lisa Lamberson, AD
Nicki Mannes, HO
Audrey Seymour, AD
Deb Vashaw, HO
Rachel Zimmer, HO
1994
Rachel Butler, AM
Laurie Byington, HO
Meredith Cashin, AD
Brooke Doornbos, C
Gina Hayward, O
Julie Hoffman, AM
Lisa Lamberson, AD
Nicki Mannes, HO
Cheryl Moore, AB
Holly Ondersma, C
Deb Quackenbush, AM
Tonya Weaver, AD
1995
Jennifer Babcock, AD
Laurie Byington, HO
Julie Hoffman, AM
Shauna Koolhaus, C
Lisa Lamberson, AD
Nicki Mannes, HO
Wendy Moore, HO
Holly Ondersma, C
Laurie Pettinga, C
Keri Roelofs, HO
Kristen Swope, HO
Tonya Weaver, AD
1996
Laurie Byington, HO
Christie Cleland, AB
Andrea Hill, AM
Melanie Harriff, C
Jennifer Holly, AM
Shauna Koolhaas, C
Lisa Larzelere, HO
Wendy Moore, HO
Megan Readler, K
Cheryl VanderKamp, C
Danelle Volk, AM
Tonya Weaver AD
1997
Angie Adams, AD
Melanie Bolt, C
Melanie Harriff, C
Andrea Hill, AM
Shuana Koolhaas, C
Lisa Larzelere, HO
Lisa Meyer, AM
Jen Miesle, AB
Heather Ozinga, HO
Becky Pierce, AM
Carrie Sheets, K
Lisa Timmer, HO
1998
Andrea Arena, SM
Brandee Brower, AM
Shauna Koolhaas, C
Lisa Larzelere, HO
Tracie Lentz, AM
Danielle Pease, AM
Becky Pierce, AM
Megan Radler, K
Marissa VanKoevering, C
Rhonda Volkers, C
Carolyn Whyte, AM
Gina Zanin, HO
1999
Brandee Brower, AM
Heather Bruder, AM
Amy Czabala, AM
Jessica Davenport, O
Kim Grotenhuis, HO
Christa Murphy, HO
Danielle Pease, AM
Becky Pierce, AM
Sara Plasman, C
Carrie Scott, HO
Rhonda Volkers, C
Gina Zanin, HO
2000
Brandee Brower, AM
Jackie Cowan, AM
Jessica Davenport, O
Kim Grotenhuis, HO
Susannah Knust, C
Jodi LaRocca, AD
Kathryn Nordin, AM
Becky Pierce, AM
Sara Plasman, C
Heather Roy, HO
Carrie Scott, HO
Darcy Stewart, AB
2001
Erin Dyksterhouse, C
Kim Grotenhuis, HO
Alana Heikkinen, AB
Jackie Knight, O
Michelle Marshall, AD
Danielle Pease, AM
Megan Russell, AB
Carrie Scott, HO
Stephanie Smith, AM
Jaime Stahl, AM
Michelle Wallace, AB
Julie Wiest, AM
2002
Andrea Adams, HO
Michaela Adams, AB
Angie Bunker, HO
Sara Caskey, AB
Elizabeth Knochel, AM
Leigh Ann LaFave, AM
Jodi LaRocca, AD
Michelle Marshall, AD
Laurel Sands, C
Meg Sheehan, HO
Stephanie Smith, AM
Abby Wilhelmi, AB
2003
Andrea Adams, HO
Kathy Beckwith, AD
Erin Carson, AM
Jeanne Cole, C
Stacey Dulinski, O
Theresa Flowers, O
Rachelle Heyboer, C
Kim Horanburg, O
Leigh Ann LaFave, AM
Kelly Kraft, HO
Megan Russell, AB
Colleen Trybus, AM
2004
Amelia Arazia, AD
Laura Bell, AM
Sarah Caskey, AB
Jeanne Cole, C
Kim Horanburg, O
Kelly Kraft, HO
Leigh Ann LaFave, AM
Lindsay Powers, AM
Kate Sajewich, SM
Beth Shunkwiler, O
Erin Sullivan, SM
Melissa Tavidian, AM
2005
Erica Anderson, OL
Jeanne Cole, C
Candace Graham, HO
Kelsey Guisbert, HO
Shannon Harrington, AM
Abby Konyndyk, C
Leigh Ann LaFave, AM
Jenn Newland, OL
Jessica Regnerus, HO
Megan Sheehan, HO
Beth Shunkwiler, OL
Melissa Tavidian, AM
2006
Emily Adams, HO
Kristin Amram, SM
Erica Anderson, OL
Rainbow Bednarski, TS
Emily Blahnik, AM
Kylee Brouwer, HO
Jeanne Cole, C
Amy Gaudard, AM
Katie Koechling, AM
Sarah Miesle, SM
Jessica Regnerus, HO
Becky Whitman, HO
2007
Kristin Amram, SM
Rainbow Bednarski, TS
Kylee Brouwer, HO
Elise English, TS
Amy Gaudard, AM
Kay McDonald, AM
Missy Morcom, AM
Jessica Regnerus, HO
Sallie Richardson, TS
Kacie Rosecrants, OL
Krissy Sheets, AD
Brittney Stensland, TS
2008
Kylee Brouwer, HO
McKenna Corrigan, SM
Kelli Duimstra, HO
Elise English, TS
Brittany Fales, AM
Karly Hooker, TS
Katie Koechling, AM
Tara Leddy, AM
Holly Lowe, AD
Missy Morcom, AM
Ashley Peterson, SM
Jessica Regnerus, HO
2009
Anna Braner, OL
Kelli Duimstra, HO
Kara Graham, TR
Kelly Koenigsknecht, AM
Tara Leddy, AM
Holly Lowe, AD
Ashley Peterson, SM
Sallie Richardson, TR
Emily Ross, AM
Jessica Stange, AB
Meghan Stevens, AD
Kelly Tomasek, AD
2010
Katie Adams, AD
Hayley Bojorquez, SM
Kelly Eberhardt, AD
Stephanie Faber, HO
Andi Gasco, TR
Sara Hivley, TR
Kelly Koenigsknecht, AM
Tara Leddy, AM
Ashley Peterson, SM
Emily Ross, AM
Tara Sipperley, TR
Meghan Stevens, AD
2011
Katie Adams, AD
Brittany Bertrand, AD
Rebecca DeWyse, AM
Kelly Eberhardt, AD
Lauren Enayati, SM
Andi Gasco, TR
Kelly Koenigsknecht, AM
Tara Leddy, AM
Abby Phillips, HO
Andrea Reinecke, HO
Tara Sipperley, TR
Kelly Treisck, TR
2012
Sarah Belote, TR
Tori Cuebas, TR
Christine Daub, O
Kelly Eberhardt, AD
Andi Gasco, TR
Sarah Hall, AD
Brooke Nienhuis, HO
Louise Rezmer, AM
Callie Selner, SM
Kayla Smart, AM
Laura Tjepkema, HO
Jordie Wasserman, SM
2013
Autumn Anderson, HO
Lina Avila, C
Sarah Belote, TR
Jillian Busfield, SM
Bree Fuller, TR
Andi Gasco, TR
Rachel Harris, TR
Louise Rezmer, AM
Amanda Schneider, AM
Carly Searles, TR
Callie Selner, SM
Laura Tjepkema, HO
2014
Autumn Anderson, HO
Lina Avila, C
Jillian Busfield, SM
Kaitlyn Clark, TR
Katie Dewyre, AD
Bree Fuller, TR
Ashlynn Grubb, OL
Lea Lusk, AM
Devan Olah, AM
Carly Searles, TR
Julie Sobieski, HO
Peyton Wells, HO
2015
Sammi Adams, HO
Autumn Anderson, HO
Kris Forest, OL
Kaylee Fox, TR
Bree Fuller, TR
Ashley Riemersma, C
Justine Robles, TR
Jamie Schnarr, TR
Carly Searles, TR
Brooke Stewart, AD
Morgan Stratton, AM
Marie Zill, AM
2016
Autumn Anderson, HO
Sarah Collier, AM
Erin DuRoss, K
Kaylee Fox, TR
Anna Gernant, C
Lydia Gildea, C
Ashlynn Grubb, OL
Kendra Marshall, TR
Justine Robles, TR
Morgan Stratton, AM (MVP)
Cassie Young, SM (MVP)
Jamie Young, SM
2017
Sammi Adams, HO
Mary Brooks, AM
Kaylee Fox, TR
Anna Gernant, C
Sydney Jones, H (MVP)
Danielle Ray, TR
Morgan Raymer, SM
Hayley Reitsma, HO
Danielle Service, AM
Morgan Stratton, AM
Cassie Young, SM (MVP)
Jamie Young, SM
2018
Mary Brooks, AM
Maddie DeGroot, C
Makenzie Duncan, SM
Kaylee Fox, TR
Anna Gernant, C
Sydney Jones, HO
Sierra Mutschler, HO
Morgan Raymer, SM (MVP)
Hayley Reitsma, HO (MVP)
Grace Stock, C
Cassie Young, SM
Jamie Young, SM